English LCCC Newsbulletin For Lebanese, Lebanese Related, Global News & Editorials
For April 13/2020
Compiled & Prepared by: Elias Bejjani

#elias_bejjani_news
 

The Bulletin's Link on the lccc Site
http://data.eliasbejjaninews.com/eliasnews21/english.april13.21.htm

 

News Bulletin Achieves Since 2006
Click Here to enter the LCCC Arabic/English news bulletins Achieves since 2006

 

Bible Quotations For today

Mary Magdalene went and announced to the disciples, ‘I have seen the Lord’
“Holy Gospel of Jesus Christ according to Saint John 20/11-18: “Mary stood weeping outside the tomb. As she wept, she bent over to look into the tomb; and she saw two angels in white, sitting where the body of Jesus had been lying, one at the head and the other at the feet. They said to her, ‘Woman, why are you weeping?’ She said to them, ‘They have taken away my Lord, and I do not know where they have laid him.’When she had said this, she turned round and saw Jesus standing there, but she did not know that it was Jesus. Jesus said to her, ‘Woman, why are you weeping? For whom are you looking?’ Supposing him to be the gardener, she said to him, ‘Sir, if you have carried him away, tell me where you have laid him, and I will take him away.’Jesus said to her, ‘Mary!’ She turned and said to him in Hebrew, ‘Rabbouni!’ (which means Teacher). Jesus said to her, ‘Do not hold on to me, because I have not yet ascended to the Father. But go to my brothers and say to them, “I am ascending to my Father and your Father, to my God and your God.” ’Mary Magdalene went and announced to the disciples, ‘I have seen the Lord’; and she told them that he had said these things to her.”

Titles For The Latest English LCCC Lebanese & Lebanese Related News & Editorials published on April 12-13/2021

Elias Bejjani/Visit My LCCC Web site/All That you need to know on Lebanese unfolding news and events in Arabic and English/http://eliasbejjaninews.com/

Lebanon Remembers Today The 46 Years Bloody Incident that is known by the Ain Al Remani Buss Incident/Elias Bejjani/April 13/2021
Ain el-Rammaneh incident/en.wikipedia.org
Health Ministry: 1008 new Corona cases, 42 deaths
Ministers of Information, Health announce Sinopharm vaccination campaign to start Monday
Abiad Expects Covid Cases Surge during Ramadan
Aoun Stresses 'National Unity' in Govt. Formation Crisis
Report: U.S. Relays ‘Strict’ Message to Lebanon on Maritime Talks
Israel Warns of Counter-Steps after Lebanon Extends Disputed Sea Area
Lebanon Extends Area Claimed in Border dispute with Israel
Najjar signs decree no. 6433 on delineation of Lebanon's EEZ boundaries
Council of Ministers’ General Secretariat refers to Republic Presidency Diab’s proposal and approval of draft decree on amendment of Decree No. 6433
Report: Hale Expected on Wednesday in Beirut
Hizbullah, Amal Say Berri's Initiative a 'Feasible Solution'
Egypt, Lebanon Announce Ramadan to Start Tuesday
Jumblatt, UK Chargé d'Affaires discuss political developments


Titles For The Latest
English LCCC Miscellaneous Reports And News published on April 12-13/2021

Iran blames Israel for nuclear plant attack, tensions escalate
Iran’s Zarif blames Israel for Natanz attack, vows revenge
Iranian Nuclear Chief Ali-Akbar Salehi One Day Before Natanz Nuclear Facility Blast: We Have Activated A Full IR-6 Centrifuge Chain; We Have Enrichment Capacity Of 16,500 SWU – More Than Before The JCPOA
Striking Natanz facility planned long before Vienna talks - sources
Pentagon chief stresses commitment to Israel amid strategic shifts
Iran Suspends Cooperation with EU in Various Fields over Sanctions
Iran Says Natanz was Hit by 'Small Explosion', Quickly Repairable
U.S. Says 'Not Involved' in Iran Nuclear Site Incident
US Defense Sec. Lloyd Austin avoids Iran talk on Israel visit
Inside Iran's efforts to lure Israelis abroad with 'honey traps'
PM Netanyahu: 'Iran is working towards Israel's annihilation'
Statement from Minister Garneau to announce the cancellation of export permits to Turkey
In Egypt, Russian top diplomat discusses trade, regional issues
Public trial looms for Prince Hamzah on charges of conspiring against the king
Turkey, Libya Renew Commitment to 2019 Maritime Deal
Germany Demands Syria be Held Accountable over Chemical Arms
Yemen's Huthi Rebels Claim Strikes on Saudi Oil Plants
Russian Prison Threatens to Force-Feed Navalny
One killed, police officer hurt in shooting at Knoxville, Tennessee high school
Canada cancels military export permits for Turkey after illegal transfers abroad

 

Titles For The Latest The Latest LCCC English analysis & editorials from miscellaneous sources published on April 12-13/2021

U.S. willing to lift sanctions imposed on Iran by Trump that are ‘inconsistent’
Karen DeYoung, Loveday Morris, Simon Denyer and Kareem Fahim/The Washington Post/April 12/2021
How Republicans Can Stop Biden from Lifting Iran Sanctions/Richard Goldberg/ National Review..FDD/April 12/2021
After Mossad report, Gantz calls for investigation into security leaks/Udi Shaham/Jerusalem Post/April 12/2021
Indoctrinated in Hate: ‘This Is the Start of the New Caliphate’/Raymond Ibrahim/Gatestone Institute/April 12/2021
Palestinian Elections: What the Biden Administration Does Not Want to Know/Khaled Abu Toameh/Gatestone Institute/April 12, 2021

 

The Latest English LCCC Lebanese & Lebanese Related News & Editorials published on April 12-13/2021

Lebanon Remembers Today The 46 Years Bloody Incident that is known by the Ain Al Remani Buss Incident

Elias Bejjani/April 13/2021

For the passed 46 years the Lebanese in general and the Lebanese Christians in particular remember on April 13th the bloody incident of the Ain Al Remani terrorist Palestinian attack. The attack targeted a church in the Ain Al Rumani Mount Lebanon Al Maten Suburb where Late Kataab leader Pierre Gemayel was attending a holy mass. Below a report on the incident.

 

Ain el-Rammaneh incident

en.wikipedia.org

https://military.wikia.org/wiki/Bus_massacre

The Bus Massacre, also known as the ‘Ain el-Rammaneh incident’ (or 'massacre'), was the collective name given to a short series of armed clashes involving Lebanese Christian and Palestinian elements in the streets of central Beirut, which is commonly presented as the spark that set off the Lebanese Civil War in the mid-1970s.
Background
Early in the morning of April 13, 1975, outside the Church of Notre Dame de la Delivrance at the predominantly Christian district of Ain el-Rammaneh in East Beirut, occurred an altercation between half a dozen armed Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) guerrillas (Arabic: Fedayyn) on a passing vehicle performing the customary waving and firing their automatic rifles into the air (Arabic: Baroud)[1] and a squad of uniformed militiamen belonging to the Phalangist Party’ Kataeb Regulatory Forces (KRF) militia who were diverting the traffic at the front of the newly consecrated temple where a family baptism was taking place. As the Palestinian militias refused to be diverted from their route, the Phalangists tried to halt their progress by force and a scuffle quickly ensued, which resulted in the death of the PLO driver of the vehicle after being shot.
At 10:30 am, when the congregation was concentrated outside the front door of the temple upon the conclusion of the ceremony, a group of unidentified gunmen approached in two civilian cars – rigged with posters and bumper stickers belonging to the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP), a PLO faction – and suddenly opened fire, killing four Phalangist militants:[2][3][4] Joseph Abu Assi, a Phalange militant and father of the baptized child and his three bodyguards – Antoine Husseini, Dib Assaf and Selman Ibrahim Abou – shot while attempting to return fire on the assailants.[citation needed] They belonged to the personal entourage of the Maronite Zaim Pierre Gemayel, the powerful leader of the right-wing Phalangist Party, who was lightly wounded in the head. The attackers fled the scene under fire from the surviving bodyguards and KRF militiamen on duty at the time.
The Bus attack
In the commotion that followed, armed Phalangist KRF and NLP Tigers militiamen took the streets, and began to set up roadblocks at Ain el-Rammaneh and other Christian-populated eastern districts of the Lebanese Capital, stopping vehicles and checked identities,[5] while in the mainly Muslim western sectors the Palestinian factions did likewise.
Assuming the perpetrators were Palestinian guerrillas who carried out the attack and outraged by the audacity of the attempt on the life of their historical leader, the Phalangists planned an immediate response. Shortly after mid-day, a PLO bus carrying Palestinian refugees,[6] of whom some were armed, returning from a political rally at Tel el-Zaatar held by the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine - General Command (PFLP-GC) passed through Ain el-Rammaneh on its way to Sabra refugee camp. The bus drove through the narrow street-alleys, where there was an armed Phalangist presence due to the earlier incident. Upon seeing it pass, the Phalangist militants opened fire on the bus, killing 27, and wounding 19. According to sociologist Samir Khalaf all 28 passengers were killed.[7]
Consequences
This bloody incident, which became known as the “Bus massacre”, incited long-standing sectarian hatred and mistrust, and sparked heavy fighting throughout the country between Kataeb Regulatory Forces militiamen and the Palestinian Fedayyn and their leftist-Muslim allies of the Lebanese National Movement (LNM) alliance, resulting in over 300 dead in just three days.[8]
The recently appointed Lebanese Prime-Minister, the Sunni Rashid al-Sulh, tried vainly to defuse the situation as quickly as possible by sending in the evening of the day following the massacre a Gendarmerie detachment from the Lebanese Internal Security Forces (ISF) to Ain el-Rammaneh, which detained a number of suspects. In addition, Prime-Minister Sulh tried to pressure Phalangist Party’ President Pierre Gemayel to hand over to the authorities the Phalangist KRF militiamen responsible for the death of the Palestinian driver. Gemayel publicly refused however, hinting that he and his Party would no longer abide by the authority of the government due to the influx of the Palestinians and PLO.[9]
He later sent a Phalangist delegation on a mission to secure the release of the previously detained suspects held in custody by Lebanese authorities, stating that the individuals involved in the incident were just defending themselves and that no charges could be pressed against them.
As news of the murders spread, armed clashes between PLO guerilla factions and other Christian militias erupted throughout the Lebanese Capital. Soon Lebanese National Movement (LNM) militias entered the fray alongside the Palestinians. Numerous ceasefires and political talks held through international mediation proved fruitless. Sporadic violence escalated into a full-fledged civil war over the next two years, known as the 1975-76 phase of the Lebanese Civil War, in which 80,000 people lost their lives and split Lebanon along factional and sectarian lines for another 16 years.
Controversy
The chain of events that led to the Ain el-Rammaneh PLO driver incident and the subsequent “Bus massacre” in April 1975 have been the subject of intense speculation and passionate debate in Lebanon since the end of the Civil War in 1990. There are two conflicting versions of what happened that day, with the Phalangists describing it as an act of self-defense by insisting that the bus carried armed ALF guerrilla reinforcements firing weapons, hurrying along to avenge their dead driver. The Phalangists anticipated such a reaction by waiting in ambush, and in the ensuing shoot-out they claimed to have killed 14 Palestinian Fedayin.[citation needed]
Although most PLO accounts deny this version of the event, describing the bus passengers as civilian families, victims of an unprovoked attack, and not fully armed guerrillas, Abd al-Rahim Ahmad of the ALF did confirm years later that some of them were off-duty members of his faction.[10] Another high-rank PLO official, Abu Iyad, later suggested that the incident was not the responsibility of the Phalange, but rather a deliberate provocation engineered by the National Liberal Party (NLP), a predominately Christian conservative Party led by former President Camille Chamoun.[11]
As for the SSNP gunmen involved in the April 1975 drive-by shooting, they were never apprehended and apparently disappeared without a trace. Some unconfirmed reports suggest that they were later killed in action.[citation needed]
The bus was found and exhibited in mid-2011.[12]
References
1-O'Ballance, Civil War in Lebanon (1998), p. 1.
2-Gordon, The Gemayels (1988), p. 48.
3-Katz, Russel & Volstad, Armies in Lebanon (1985), p. 4.
4-Hirst, David (2010). Beware of small states: Lebanon, battleground of the Middle East. Nation Books. p. 99.
5-Katz, Russel & Volstad, Armies in Lebanon (1985), p. 5.
6-Hirst, David (2010). Beware of small states: Lebanon, battleground of the Middle East. Nation Books. p. 99.
7-Khalaf, Samir (2002): Civil and Uncivil Violence in Lebanon: A History of the Internationalization of Human Contact; New York: Columbia University Press; p. 228f
8-Harris, Faces of Lebanon (1997), p. 161.
9-O'Ballance, Civil War in Lebanon (1998), p. 2.
10-ersonal interview with Rex Brynen in Amman, Jordan, December 28, 1986
11-Abu Iyad, My Home, My Land (1981), p. 164.

 

Health Ministry: 1008 new Corona cases, 42 deaths
NNA/April 12/2021
The Ministry of Public Health announced, on Monday, the registration of 1008 new Corona infections, thus raising the cumulative number of confirmed cases to-date to 497,854.
It also indicated that 42 deaths were recorded during the past 24 hours.

Ministers of Information, Health announce Sinopharm vaccination campaign to start Monday
NNA /April 12/2021
Caretaker Ministers Manal Abdel Samad of Information and Hamad Hassan of Public Health on Monday held a joint press conference at the Public Health Ministry in Jnah, during which they announced the details of the vaccination campaign for the media body, security corps, and public sector employees, which is expected to start upcoming Monday. The Lebanese University headquarters in Hadath has been assigned as the vaccination center for the targeted sectors set to receive the Sinopharm COVID-19 vaccines, granted by the state of China to the Ministry of Public Health. 10 clinics have been set up for this purpose at the University premises. The press conference was attended by the President of the Lebanese University (LU), Professor Fouad Ayyoub, ,and a number of representatives of the targeted sectors in this campaign. Ministers Hassan and Abdel Samad declared during the press conference that "text messages will be sent out within 10 days from now to all concerned sectors’ employees registered on the Covax platform to choose the appointment date for vaccination."Minister Hassan said at the press conference that out of the Sinopharm COVID-19 vaccines received by the Ministry of Public Health as a donation from China, ten thousand vaccines have been allocated to the army command, with forty thousand vaccines remaining. In turn, Minister Abdel Samad said: "18 percent of media professionals have contracted the infection since the start of the pandemic, which is a huge number compared to the general infection rate, which is 7 percent." "This high rate confirms the righteousness of our demand to include media professionals among the priorities,” the Minister said. Abdel Samad stressed that "all vaccines approved by the Ministry of Health are safe and meet the specified conditions, and as such favoring between one vaccine and another is dropped." Prior to the press conference, Abdel Samad handed Minister Hassan, the mechanism devised by the Ministry of Information for the vaccination of media professionals.

Abiad Expects Covid Cases Surge during Ramadan
Naharnet/April 12/2021
Director of the Rafik Hariri University Hospital, Firass Abiad, said on Monday that the number of covid-19 cases are expected to rise during the holy month of Ramadan due to the ritual gatherings practiced during the month of fasting. n“With the start of the holy month, mobility and contact will be on the rise. Whether at homes, restaurants, or places of worship, people will gather to do what people on this occasion do. Many will have masks on, though it will be difficult to keep them on while eating,” said Abiad in a tweet. He said the virus will surely spread further with the new more contagious variants. “Some will observe the distancing restrictions, though as we now know, more contagious virus variants circulating through the air render many of the old measures less effective. With more than 2000 new cases reported daily and many more flying in, the virus will surely spread further,” he tweeted. Abiad urged people to be more vigilant, and wished “strength” for the healthcare workers on the front lines providing care to patients with and without the virus.

Aoun Stresses 'National Unity' in Govt. Formation Crisis
Naharnet/April 12/2021
President Michel Aoun on Monday stressed that “national unity” should be preserved in the approach towards the formation of the new government. “I sensed from His Excellency the President his insistence on honoring the principle of national unity in his dealing with the government formation crisis,” Central Council of the Maronite Societies chief Wadih al-Khazen said after meeting Aoun in Baabda. “He rejected the ‘guaranteeing’ or ‘blocking one-third’ claims, warning against allowing the growing crisis to impact the country’s future and expressing concern over the fate of the promised aid,” Khazen added. “The President will carry on with the consultations that he is making in order to produce a quick solution leading to the formation of a rescue and mission-driven government that would oversee the proper implementation of the forensic audit, which has been launched and will target all state sectors,” the ex-minister went on to say.

Report: U.S. Relays ‘Strict’ Message to Lebanon on Maritime Talks
Naharnet/April 12/2021
The United States reportedly relayed a “strict” message to Lebanon through the US Ambassador to Lebanon, Dorothy Shea, regarding the indirect maritime demarcation talks between Lebanon and Israel, media reports said on Monday. According to private news portal, Lebanon Debate, Lebanese authorities received a firm message from Shea stipulating that Israel will withdraw completely from the demarcation negotiations with Lebanon, and will start exploration in the disputed area, if the maritime boundary decree is amended and Line 29 is approved. The first round of indirect negotiations to demarcate the maritime border between Lebanon and Israel began on October 14, under a US mediation and the auspices of the United Nations. The talks aim to resolve a dispute over their maritime borders, which has hindered oil and gas exploration in the potentially gas-rich region. The latest session of talks between Israel and Lebanon was put off after Israel accused Lebanon of inconsistency. The two sides have been negotiating based on a map registered with the United Nations in 2011, which shows an 860-square-kilometer patch of sea as being disputed. But Lebanon considers that map to have been based on wrong estimates and now demands an additional 1,430 square kilometers of sea farther south, which includes part of Israel's Karish gas field, according to Lebanese energy expert Laury Haytayan.

Israel Warns of Counter-Steps after Lebanon Extends Disputed Sea Area
Naharnet/April 12/2021
Israeli Energy Minister Yuval Steinitz on Monday warned that any “unilateral” Lebanese steps regarding the sea border demarcation will be met by “Israeli counter-steps,” shortly after a Lebanese minister said he had signed a decree that would increase the area claimed by Lebanon.
“It seems that Lebanon prefers to torpedo the negotiations instead of making an attempt to reach solutions,” Steinitz said, according to Russia’s RT Arabic television. “This is not the first time in the past 20 years that the Lebanese have changed their maritime maps for propaganda purposes and to express a ‘patriotic stance’, and by this they are obstructing themselves one time after another,” the Israeli minister added.“At a time other countries in the region such as Israel, Egypt and Cyprus have been developing their natural gas fields for several years to provide prosperity to their citizens, the Lebanese are staying behind and launching fiery statements that will achieve nothing,” Steinitz added.

Lebanon Extends Area Claimed in Border dispute with Israel
Associated Press/April 12/2021
Outgoing minister of public works Michel Najjar said Monday that he has signed a decree that would increase the area claimed by the Mediterranean country in a maritime border dispute with Israel. Najjar told reporters that he has signed an amendment of the decree that would formally extend Lebanon's claims by 1,430 square kilometers (550 square miles). The unilateral move by Lebanon is likely to anger Israel and the U.S. who are not expected to recognize Beirut's extension of the disputed area. Lebanon and Israel began indirect talks with U.S. mediation in October to reach a deal over the disputed area that is believed to be rich with oil and natural gas deposits. The meetings that stopped few weeks later were being held at a U.N. post along the border of the two nations that remain technically in a state of war. The negotiations were the first non-security talks to be held between the two countries, which have no diplomatic relations following decades of conflict. Resolving the border issue could pave the way for lucrative oil and gas deals on both sides. In late October, the Lebanese delegation to the talks — a mix of army generals and professionals — offered a new map that pushes for an additional 1,430 square kilometers (550 square miles). This area is to be included in Lebanese territory on top of the already disputed 860 square kilometer- (330 square mile-) area of the Mediterranean Sea that each side claims is within their own exclusive economic zones. Najjar said, however, that the decree still required the signatures of the defense minister, prime minister and president to go into effect. Later in the day, the decree was signed by caretaker PM Hassan Diab and caretaker Deputy PM and Defense Minister Zeina Akar. The announcement came as U.S. Under Secretary of State for Political Affairs David Hale was expected in Lebanon later this weeks to meet Lebanese officials. Lebanon is passing through its worst economic and financial crisis in its modern history and had plans to start drilling in search for oil and gas in the disputed area this year. Israel has already developed offshore natural gas rigs, producing enough for domestic consumption and export abroad. Lebanon hopes that its own oil and gas discoveries will help alleviate its long-running economic troubles. It was not immediately how the U.S. and Israel would respond to the Lebanese decision.

Najjar signs decree no. 6433 on delineation of Lebanon's EEZ boundaries

NNA/April 12/2021
Caretaker Minister of Public Works and Transportation, Michel Najjar, announced Monday that he had signed decree no. 6433 on the delineation of the boundaries of the Exclusive Economic Zone of Lebanon. "The decree is now in the hands of the General Secretariat of the Presidency of the Council of Ministers," Najjar told a news conference. "Caretaker Prime Minister Hassan Diab said that he would sign," he added.

Council of Ministers’ General Secretariat refers to Republic Presidency Diab’s proposal and approval of draft decree on amendment of Decree No. 6433
NNA/April 12/2021
The Press Office of the Presidency of the Council of Ministers issued the following statement: The General Secretariat of the Council of Ministers referred to the Presidency of the Republic the proposal and approval of caretaker prime minister, Hassan Diab, on the draft decree relating to the amendment of Decree No. 6433, dated October 1, 2011, after it was signed by Ministers of Defense, Zeina Akar and Public Works and Transport, Michel Najjar, in order to obtain the exceptional approval by the President of the Republic for issuance in accordance with the due process followed for all files that need to be brought to the attention of the Council of Ministers. The relevant approval by the Council of Ministers shall be replaced by the exceptional approval of the President of the Republic and the Prime Minister, provided that the issue is subsequently presented before the Council of Ministers for settlement.-- Caretaker PM Press office

Report: Hale Expected on Wednesday in Beirut

Naharnet/April 12/2021
As part of the international mobility towards Lebanon, the U.S. Under Secretary of State for Middle East Affairs David Hale will arrive in Beirut on Wednesday to meet senior Lebanese officials, media reports said Monday. Hale’s visit is his last to Lebanon and the region before leaving his post at the end of this month. Lebanon was officially informed of Hale’s visit to Beirut that extends for several days as part of a tour to a number of countries in the region. According to media reports, Hale --one of the first to manage the file demarcating the maritime borders between Lebanon and Israel-- aims to reactivate the indirect maritime border talks in Naqoura between the two countries. Hale arrives in Lebanon at a "sensitive" internal and regional political moment. No doubt that he will have an opinion and position on the Lebanese crisis in general, specifically with regard to the formation of the government and the financial, economic and monetary collapse, said al-Akhbar daily.

Hizbullah, Amal Say Berri's Initiative a 'Feasible Solution'
Naharnet/April 12/2021
Hizbullah and the Amal Movement held a consultative meeting Monday and discussed the various political files, topped by the file of the formation of a new government, a joint statement said. The conferees stressed “the need to finalize the cabinet line-up as soon as possible,” adding that the formation of the new government would allow authorities to “address citizens’ issues and concerns.”They accordingly called for “supporting all the efforts that are being exerted in this regard, especially Parliament Speaker Nabih Berri’s initiative,” describing it as “a feasible solution that can satisfy all components.”Earlier in the day, Amal had warned that “delaying, or rather obstructing, the government’s formation is tantamount to treason against the Lebanese.”

Egypt, Lebanon Announce Ramadan to Start Tuesday
Agence France Presse/April 12/2021
The Muslim holy fasting month of Ramadan will begin on Tuesday April 13 in Egypt and Lebanon, religious authorities in the two countries announced Sunday. "April 13 will be the first day of Ramadan," said Egypt's Dar al-Ifta, the institution that issues religious edicts in the Arab world's most populous country. In Lebanon, top Sunni Muslim cleric Grand Mufti Sheikh Abdellatif Deryan also confirmed the holy month would begin on Tuesday. The start of Ramadan is set by both lunar calculations and physical sightings that determine when one month ends and another begins. Saudi Arabia, custodian of Islam's two holiest sites, said the crescent moon, which is used to establish the beginning of the month, was not visible Sunday and that observation committees would meet again on Monday night. Ramadan fasting is one of the five pillars of Islam. Observant Muslims refrain from eating and drinking from dawn to dusk, and traditionally gather with family and friends to break their fast in the evening. It is also a time of prayers, during which Muslims typically converge in large numbers at mosques, especially at night. But due to the Covid-19 pandemic, many Muslim-majority countries have imposed restrictions on worshippers including night-time curfews, and called for prayers to be performed at home.

Jumblatt, UK Chargé d'Affaires discuss political developments
NNA/April 12/2021
Progressive Socialist Party Chief, Walid Jumblatt, on Monday welcomed, at Clemenceau, the UK Chargé d'Affaires in Lebanon, Dr. Martin Longden, with talks reportedly touching on the latest political developments.
 

The Latest English LCCC Miscellaneous Reports And News published on April 12-13/2021

Iran blames Israel for nuclear plant attack, tensions escalate
The Arab Weekly/April 12/2021
TEHRAN/ LONDON - Iran has blamed regional arch-foe Israel for a sabotage incident at its key Natanz nuclear site and threatened to exact revenge, in what appeared to be latest episode in a long-running covert war. Iran’s semi-official Nournews website said the person who caused an electricity outage in one of the production halls at the underground uranium enrichment plant had been identified. “Necessary measures are being taken to arrest this person,” the website reported, without giving details about the person. The incident occurred amid diplomatic efforts by Iran and the United States to revive Tehran’s 2015 nuclear deal with major powers, an accord Israel fiercely opposed, after former US President Donald Trump abandoned it three years ago. Last week, Iran and the global powers held what they described as “constructive” talks to salvage the deal, which has unravelled as Iran has breached its limits on sensitive uranium enrichment since Trump reimposed harsh sanctions on Tehran. Iranian authorities described the incident a day earlier as an act of “nuclear terrorism” and said Tehran reserved the right to take action against the perpetrators. On Monday, Foreign Minister Mohammad Javad Zarif explicitly blamed Israel. “The Zionists want to take revenge because of our progress in the way to lift sanctions…They have publicly said that they will not allow this. But we will take our revenge against the Zionists,” Zarif was quoted by state TV as saying. Multiple Israeli media outlets have quoted unnamed intelligence sources as saying the country’s Mossad spy service carried out a successful sabotage operation at the underground Natanz complex, potentially setting back enrichment work there by months. Israel has not formally commented on the incident.
Enrichment moves
The incident took place a day after Tehran, which has insisted it wants only peaceful nuclear energy not nuclear weapons, started new advanced enrichment centrifuges at Natanz. Iranian Foreign Ministry spokesman Saeed Khatibzadeh told a news conference on Monday that the incident could be deemed an “act against humanity”, adding it had caused “no contamination or casualties” at the site. “Our nuclear experts are assessing the damage but I can assure you that Iran will replace damaged uranium enrichment centrifuges in Natanz with advanced ones,” Khatibzadeh said. “The answer for Natanz is to take revenge against Israel,” Khatibzadeh said. “Israel will receive its answer through its own path.” He did not elaborate. Khatibzadeh acknowledged that IR-1 centrifuges, the first-generation workhorse of Iran’s uranium enrichment, had been damaged in the attack, but did not elaborate. State television has yet to show images from the facility.
— US visit —
The incident also coincided with a visit to Israel by US. Secretary of Defence Lloyd Austin, who pledged the Biden administration’s support for its Middle East ally. “I’m committed to continuing our close consultations on threats posed by Iran and to strengthening Israel’s security,” Austin tweeted late on Sunday. A senior US administration official said Washington had no involvement in the incident. “We have nothing to add to speculation about the causes,” the official said. At a ceremony on Sunday, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu made no direct reference to Natanz, though said: “The fight against Iran’s nuclearisation…is a massive task.”There have been sporadic incidents of sabotage and outages at Iranian nuclear installations for over a decade, for which Tehran has blamed Israel, which regards the Iranian nuclear programme as a menace to its existence. In 2010, the Stuxnet computer virus, widely believed to have been developed by the United States and Israel, was discovered after it was used to attack Natanz, causing damaging breakdowns of centrifuge cascades that refine uranium. In July last year, a fire broke out at Natanz that Iran said was an attempt to sabotage its enrichment activity. Iran also blamed Israel for last November’s assassination of Mohsen Fakhrizadeh, who was seen by Western intelligence services as the mastermind of a covert Iranian nuclear weapons programme. Israel has neither confirmed nor denied responsibility for the killing.

 

Iran’s Zarif blames Israel for Natanz attack, vows revenge

Jerusalem Post/April 12/2021
The foreign minister’s comments on Monday morning appear to be building to a crescendo that could indicate Iran intends to retaliate. Iranian Foreign Minister Javad Zarif on Monday blamed Israel for Sunday’s incident at the Natanz nuclear facility. An increasing number of Iranian officials have described the incident as sabotage or terrorism. Zarif’s comments appeared on state television Monday morning. “The Zionists want to take revenge because of our progress on the way to lift sanctions... they have publicly said they will not allow this,” he said. “But we will take our revenge on the Zionists.” An act of “nuclear terrorism” had taken place, Iranian nuclear chief Ali Akbar Salehi said Sunday afternoon. The attack was carried out by “opponents of the country’s industrial and political progress, who aim to prevent development of a thriving nuclear industry,” he was quoted as saying. Zarif’s comments on Monday appeared to indicate that Iran intends to retaliate. In the 24 hours after the damage was first reported, and was first ascribed to a failed electrical grid, increasing details have emerged about a major setback to Iran’s nuclear program. Tehran boasted on Saturday about using new advanced centrifuges at Natanz. Last week, an Iranian ship was allegedly attacked in the Red Sea, which The New York Times ascribed to Israel. Iranian media outlets have been quieter about the incident at Natanz. It was not front-page news on Tasnim News Agency, the semi-official Fars News Agency and some other Iranian channels. This may be because Tehran wants to message one thing to the international community, complaining about sabotage and Israel, while messaging something else at home. It has boasted about its successes at Natanz, a facility that was sabotaged last July. Tehran has said the facility is more secure, which makes Sunday’s incident embarrassing. Iran wants to feed information to its pro-Iran lobby in the West, where it pretends to be a victim and where Iranian “moderates” are portrayed as embattled and in need of support via a new Iran deal. Iran tries to present Israel as sabotaging that deal. It also uses narratives about a possible conflict in the region to threaten Western countries.

 

Iranian Nuclear Chief Ali-Akbar Salehi One Day Before Natanz Nuclear Facility Blast: We Have Activated A Full IR-6 Centrifuge Chain; We Have Enrichment Capacity Of 16,500 SWU – More Than Before The JCPOA
MEMRI/April 12, 2021
Ali-Akbar Salehi, Head of the Atomic Energy Organization of Iran said that Iran has activated a full chain of 164 IR-6 centrifuges in the Natanz nuclear facility. Salehi's remarks were made in an interview that aired on channel 1 (Iran) on April 10, 2021, one day before the Natanz facility suffered a major explosion. He said that this chain was originally planned to be activated in seven or eight years. Salehi described nuclear progress in the Fordow facility, and said that Iran now has an enrichment capacity of 16,500 SWU, while it only had a capacity of 13,000 SWU before the JCPOA was signed in 2013. He said that it has been announced that the hall, in which the centrifuges are assembled at the Natanz facility has been restored and is back in operation, after it was damaged and put out of use in a 2020 explosion.
Salehi went on to say that the current facility in Natanz is scheduled to move deep into the mountains of Natanz by the end of the year. He added that Iran has surpassed a "technological threshold" and can now design centrifuges on its own, without resorting to reverse engineering. Salehi said that Iran is capable of producing 190,000 SWU using IR-6 centrifuges within two or three years, but it does not want to do so, but rather it prefers to proceed at a pace of "natural growth."
To view the clip of Iranian nuclear chief Ali-Akbar Salehi on MEMRI TV, click here or below.
"We [Have] Activated A Full Chain Of IR-6 Centrifuges... Soon, Another Cascade Will Be Activated In Fordow"
Ali-Akbar Salehi: "Today, we activated a full chain of IR-6 centrifuges, and not a test chain. This full chain of IR-6 centrifuges was meant to be activated in 7-8 years.
"Obviously, according to the law passed by the Majles, we must produce and install 1,000 IR-6 centrifuges within a year. Today, we activated [in Natanz] a chain of 164 centrifuges. Soon, another cascade will be activated in Fordow. Two cascades are supposed to be activated in Fordow.
"Now We Have 16,500 SWU," More Than Before The JCPOA, "And This Capacity Is Constantly Growing"
"In the past three months, we have activated 1,000 IR-2M centrifuges. We have installed two IR-4 chains, these are full chains, not test chains. We now have enrichment capacity of 16,500 SWU. Our maximal enrichment capacity before the JCPOA - before 2013 - was 13,000 SWU. Now we have 16,500 SWU and this capacity is constantly growing. All of this is without using the IR-1 centrifuges that we pulled out as part of the JCPOA. If we added those, our capacity would have surpassed 25,000 SWU. However, we are taking slow and calculated steps forward.
"We [Have] Managed To Build A Hall Instead Of The One That Was Lost [In The July 2020 Explosion]; We Are Working 24/7 To Move All Our Sensitive Halls Into The Heart Of The Mountain Near Natanz"
"Unfortunately, about 10 months ago, the enemy blew up the hall, in which our centrifuges are assembled. But we did not stop. Today, it was announced that we had managed to build a hall instead of the one that was lost. This is temporary, of course. Currently, we are working 24/7 to move all our sensitive halls into the heart of the mountain near Natanz. We hope that these halls in the heart of the mountain will be ready by next year, so we can move these facilities to them. With regard to enrichment, I can tell you that Iran has reached the technological threshold, and we no longer have any problems. We are designing our own [centrifuges], and no longer in need of reverse engineering.
"If The Goal Is To Produce 1900,000 SWU Using IR-6 Centrifuges – We Can Do It In 2-3 Years, But We Don't Want To"
"The IR-9 centrifuge is about 5-meter long. It is a real monster. It has a large diameter and is very tall. It has 5 bellows. You cannot build a 5-meter rotor, because it could cause problems once it starts rotating. The rotors are divided to parts that connect to one another. The parts that connect the rotors are called the bellows. So this centrifuge has five bellows. So what are we doing? In order to test this centrifuge, our engineers do it at first with one sub-critical rotor. Then they install two rotors, one on top of the other, and so on. It takes 10 years to pass through all these phases and bring the IR-9 centrifuges to industrial production. Today we unveiled the sub-critical and one-bellow centrifuges. We already built the 5-bellow centrifuge and started it, but we must begin from the no-bellow phase and proceed in the natural technical stages.
"If the goal is to produce 1900,000 SWU using IR-6 centrifuges - we can do it in 2-3 years, but we don't want to. We want to proceed according to the natural growth, and this requires another discussion."


Striking Natanz facility planned long before Vienna talks - sources
Jerusalem Post/April 12/2021
At the time the operation was planned, it was still unclear exactly when and if the US and Iran would return to serious negotiations regarding a return to the 2015 nuclear deal. The strike on Iran’s key Natanz nuclear facility was prepared long before the ongoing Vienna nuclear talks between Iran and the world powers, The Jerusalem Post has learned. Although it is quite possible that the exact timing of the attack, which is being widely attributed to Israel either as a physical or cyberattack, was eventually given a final green light to set the Islamic Republic back at the negotiating table, the operation itself was in the works long before. At the time the operation was planned, it was still unclear exactly when and if the US and Iran would return to serious negotiations regarding a return to the 2015 nuclear deal, though it has been known for a long time that this was the professed intention of US President Joe Biden.
Previously, the Post has reported that planning of the now legendary Mossad January 2018 raid of Iran’s nuclear secrets started from the beginning of Mossad Director Yossi Cohen in early 2016. Whether an operation is physical or cyber can also impact how long the planning takes since there are large differences in terms of how many operatives might be required on the ground. With the New York Times report that the latest strike has brought down the Natanz electrical system for as many as nine months, there could be a major impact on the strength of Tehran’s negotiating position in Vienna.
Despite the importance to the specific negotiations, the impression given to the Post is that the covert war against Iran is ongoing and constant and focused on preventing it from getting close to the nuclear threshold regardless of the world powers’ specific policy on the issue at any given moment. Though early Sunday Iran had tried to play down the Natanz event as an "accident," by mid-morning the Post had reported the event was intentional and far graver than the Islamic Republic was admitting. Later Sunday, other outlets and the Iranians started to report additional details about the severity of the event.

 

Pentagon chief stresses commitment to Israel amid strategic shifts
The Arab Weekly/April 12/2021
TEL AVIV - US Defence Secretary Lloyd Austin on Sunday declared an “enduring and ironclad” American commitment to Israel, reinforcing support at a tense time in Israeli politics and amid questions about the Biden administration’s efforts to revive nuclear negotiations with Israel’s archenemy, Iran.
Austin’s first talks in Israel since he became Pentagon chief in January come as the United States seeks to leverage Middle East diplomatic progress made by the Trump administration, which brokered a deal normalising relations between Israel and several Arab states.
After meeting Defence Minister Benny Gantz in Tel Aviv, Austin said he had reaffirmed “our commitment to Israel is enduring and ironclad.” Austin made no mention of Iran. Gantz, in his own remarks while standing beside Austin, said his country views the United States as a “full partner” against threats, “not the least, Iran.” Neither official took questions from reporters.
“The Tehran of today presents a strategic threat to international security, the entire Middle East and to the state of Israel,” Gantz said in his prepared statement. “We will work closely with our American allies to ensure that any new agreement with Iran will secure the vital interests of the world and of the United States, prevent a dangerous arms race in our region and protect the state of Israel.”Yoel Guzansky, a senior fellow at the Institute for National Security Studies, a Tel Aviv think tank, said Austin’s visit is important in part because it is the first by a member of President Joe Biden’s cabinet.
“They want to show that they did come here with clean hands and they want to listen,” Guzansky said. “They want to listen to Israel’s worries and perhaps other partners’ worries about the negotiation about Iran.” Austin is steeped in the finer points of Middle East defence and security issues. He served four years as head of US Central Command, capping a 41-year Army career that included commanding US forces in Iraq. Flying overnight from Washington, Austin arrived in Tel Aviv in the tense aftermath of the country’s fourth inconclusive election in the past two years. Israeli president Reuven Rivlin last week gave embattled prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu the difficult task of trying to form a new government. The key backdrop to Austin’s visit is the Israeli government’s concern about the Biden administration’s attempt to work out an arrangement to reenter the Iran nuclear deal, which in Israel’s view is fatally flawed. Netanyahu has for years described Iran as an existential threat to his nation due to Iran’s alleged pursuit of a nuclear weapon and its support for militant groups like Lebanon’s Hezbollah. Netanyahu, leading a state with its own secret nuclear weapons programme, has accused Iran of seeking nuclear weapons to use with its ballistic missiles. Iran has maintained its nuclear programme is peaceful. Netanyahu has also kept up his criticism of the Iran nuclear deal, which, if followed, strictly limits Tehran’s ability to enrich and stockpile uranium, blocking it from being able to make a weapon.
“History has taught us that deals like this, with extremist regimes like this, are worth nothing,” Netanyahu said last week.
By coincidence or not, Austin’s arrived as Iran reported that its underground Natanz nuclear facility lost power Sunday just hours after starting up new advanced centrifuges capable of enriching uranium faster. Israel’s likely involvement in the incident will further heightens tensions between Iran and Israel, already engaged in a shadow conflict across the wider Middle East that includes Israeli naval attacks in the waters of the region and air strikes in Syria. Last week, an Iranian ship said to be acting as a Revolutionary Guard base off the coast of Yemen was struck by an explosion. Iran blamed Israel for the blast. In addition to repeated assurances by Republican and Democratic administrations that the United States will endeavuor to preserve Israel’s qualitative military edge over its regional adversaries, Washington for years has invested heavily in helping Israel develop missile defense technologies.
Iron Dome is one of the most-touted successes in Israel missile defence. It is a mobile anti-rocket system developed to intercept short-range unguided rockets. It has shot down more than 2,000 projectiles fired from the Gaza Strip since it was deployed a decade ago. The US Army recently bought two Iron Dome batteries at the request of Congress to counter cruise missiles. There are questions in Israel about US intentions in shifting military priorities away from the Middle East in order to focus more intensively on China and Russia as more significant threats to US security.
Iran is the central source of concern for Israel and for Israeli support groups in the United States. The Jewish Institute for National Security of America, or JINSA, argued in a report last week that such a shift in US priorities would “send the wrong” signal as the Biden administration begins indirect talks with Iran on reviving the 2015 nuclear deal with international powers. President Donald Trump withdrew from it in 2018. “With reduced defensive capabilities and perceived American retrenchment from the region, Tehran and its proxies will only be incentivised to pursue even more dangerous actions to destabilise its neighbours,” the JINSA report said. Michael Makovsky, the president of JINSA and a former Pentagon official, said Austin’s visit is especially timely, given the Biden administration’s moves toward engaging Iran on its nuclear programme. “Embracing and strengthening Israel sends a pointed signal to Iran, which will only enhance a credible military option against Iran and US leverage in the talks,” Makovsky said in a statement.

 

Iran Suspends Cooperation with EU in Various Fields over Sanctions
Agence France Presse/April 12/2021
Iran's foreign ministry said Monday it is suspending cooperation with the European Union in various fields following the bloc's decision to blacklist several Iranian security officials over a 2019 protest crackdown. Foreign ministry spokesman Saeed Khatibzadeh "strongly condemned" the sanctions and said Iran is "suspending all human rights talks and cooperation resulting from these talks with the EU, especially in (the fields of) terrorism, drugs and refugees." He said Iran rejects "such actions from those falsely claiming to champion human rights", adding Tehran is considering reciprocal sanctions. The EU added eight Iranian security officials, including the commander of the Islamic republic's Revolutionary Guards, and three prisons to its sanctions blacklist, effective immediately with publication in the bloc's official journal. The listing said Guards commander Hossein Salami "bears responsibility for serious human rights violations." Also hit with sanctions is the head of the Basij paramilitary force, the commander of the Revolutionary Guards' ground forces and Iran's police chief. In November 2019, a surprise fuel price hike sparked a wave of protests across Iran, before they were put down amid a near-total internet shutdown. At least 304 people died in the unrest, according to London-based Amnesty International, while some authorities in Iran have announced 230 deaths during what they called "riots". The move to impose asset freezes and visa bans comes at a sensitive time, as Brussels mediates efforts to revive a troubled nuclear deal between world powers and Tehran. The U.S. withdrew from the accord in 2018 and reimposed punishing sanctions on Iran that had been lifted in exchange for limits on its nuclear program. Negotiations in Vienna are currently focused on trying to persuade Washington to drop sanctions and Tehran to roll back breaches of the agreement made in retaliation. Khatibzadeh accused the bloc of having "stayed silent in the face of" Washington's sanctions and only "expressing regret," while "cooperating" with the U.S. Iran's President Hassan Rouhani had on several occasions threatened to cease all cooperation with Europe on drug trafficking and refugee flows if the bloc did not help the Islamic republic circumvent U.S. sanctions. The United Nations has praised Iran for hosting millions of refugees fleeing conflict in Afghanistan, which is also a major producer of illicit drugs. Iran regularly announces large-scale seizures of opioids from the neighboring country.

 

Iran Says Natanz was Hit by 'Small Explosion', Quickly Repairable
Agence France Presse/April 12/2021
The Atomic Energy Organization of Iran said Monday its Natanz plant was hit by a "small explosion" the previous day, after the government labelled it an Israeli act of "sabotage.""The incident occurred at the electricity distribution center. There was a small explosion," AEOI spokesman Behrouz Kamalvandi told the Tasnim news agency, adding that the "damaged sectors can be quickly repaired."
 

U.S. Says 'Not Involved' in Iran Nuclear Site Incident
Agence France Presse/April 12/2021
The White House on Monday said the United States had nothing to do with what Iran says was a sabotage attack on its Natanz uranium enrichment plant. "The U.S. was not involved in any manner," Press Secretary Jen Psaki told reporters. "We have nothing to add on speculation about the causes or the impacts."

 

US Defense Sec. Lloyd Austin avoids Iran talk on Israel visit
Jerusalem Post/April 12/2021
Austin’s visit took place less than 100 days into the Biden administration, and was the first for a Biden cabinet member.
US Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin studiously avoided any mention of Iran and its nuclear ambitions in his public statements on a two-day visit to Israel, even when his interlocutors highlighted the issue. Austin’s visit took place less than 100 days into the Biden administration, and was the first for a Biden cabinet member. It came as the US was engaged in indirect talks with Iran to return to the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action, the full name of the 2015 nuclear agreement between Tehran and world powers, and following recent attacks on an Iranian intelligence base at sea and its Natanz underground nuclear facility, attributed to Israel. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said following a meeting with Austin on Tuesday that, “in the Middle East, there is no threat more serious or dangerous or pressing than that [of] the fanatical regime in Iran.
“Iran continues to support terrorists around the world…and has never given up its quest for nuclear weapons and missiles. Iran consistently and outrageously calls for Israel’s annihilation,” he said, and referring to Holocaust Remembrance Day last week, added: “When we say it could never happen again, we mean we will never let it happen again.”
Netanyahu said that he “will never allow Iran to obtain the nuclear capability to attain the genocidal goal of destroying Israel,” adding that the US and Israel agree that Iran must not possess nuclear weapons. Austin’s remarks were about the robust US-Israel defense relationship, more generally.
“I reaffirm the administration’s strong commitment to Israel and the Israeli people,” he said. “I thought it was important that we meet face-to-face to express our earnest desire for close consultations with Israel as we address shared challenges in the region.” Biden administration officials, including Secretary of State Antony Blinken, have said they will consult with Israel and other allies in the Middle East about nuclear talks with Iran. Austin pledged to strengthen Israel’s security and ensure its qualitative military edge, and expressed support for efforts to normalize relations between Israel and Arab- and Muslim-majority countries. “As we advance shared defense priorities and maintain close cooperation between the US and Israel, I am confident that together we can chart a path toward enduring peace in the reason,” he stated. The US secretary of defense also spoke of being moved by his visit to Yad Vashem on Tuesday, and said that the memory of the victims and survivors of the Holocaust must “always be a solemn reminder of our duty to be ever-vigilant against mass atrocities.” Austin did not mention Iran in his remarks after a meeting with Defense Minister Benny Gantz on Sunday. Gantz said that “the Tehran of today poses a strategic threat to international security, to the entire Middle East and to the State of Israel, and we will work closely with our American allies to ensure that any new agreement with Iran will secure the vital interests of the world, of the US, prevent a dangerous arms race in our region and protect the State of Israel.”Austin did, however, mention Iran in a tweet hours after his meeting with Gantz. "Thank you [Minister of Defense] Gantz for today’s important discussions on the regional threat environment and ways to deepen U.S.-Israel defense cooperation. I’m committed to continuing our close consultations on threats posed by Iran and to strengthening Israel’s security," he wrote.
Ahead of Austin’s visit, senior Israeli officials said Iran would be a top item on the agenda for his meetings.


Inside Iran's efforts to lure Israelis abroad with 'honey traps'
Arutz Sheva/April 12/2021
Israeli authorities reveal Iran's techniques for trying to lure Israelis into ambushes abroad using fictitious female profiles as lures. Israel’s Mossad and Shin Bet agencies said Monday afternoon that the Iranian military is working to lure Israelis abroad, with the intention of ambushing or kidnapping them.
According to the two Israeli security agencies, Iranian intelligence units are using an adaptation of the ‘honey trap’ technique to lure Israeli citizens overseas. In this case, Iranian teams looking to harm or kidnap Israeli nationals use fictitious social media accounts on outlets such as Instagram, posing as young women who work in the travel or tourism industries.The Iranian teams use the fake accounts to make contact with Israelis and eventually to lure them into either business meetings or romantic encounters abroad. The Shin Bet and Mossad said that such efforts were being conducted not only directly from Iran, but also from other countries including a number of Arab states, Turkey, Caucasus states, several African states, and a number of European countries. This tactic, the Israeli intelligence agencies said, has been used by Iranian forces in the past, including against critics of the Islamic regime within Iran. Now, Iran’s focus has shifted towards Israeli citizens, in particular businessmen who often travel abroad in connection with their work.

PM Netanyahu: 'Iran is working towards Israel's annihilation'
Arutz Sheva/April 12/2021
Prime Minister Netanyahu meets with US Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin at the Prime Minister's Office in Jerusalem. Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu met Monday with US Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin at the Prime Minister's Office in Jerusalem. Secretary Austin is the first senior official from the Biden administration to visit Israel. The two discussed a number of issues, including continuing military trade between the two countries, maintaining Israel's qualitative military edge, and deepening intelligence cooperation in the region. Other issues discussed include the US presence in the Middle East, the nuclear agreement with Iran and the Iranian aggression in the Middle East, and strengthening regional cooperation, such as relations with Jordan, Egypt and other Gulf states. Earlier on Monday, Austin met with Israeli Defense Minister Benny Gantz (Blue and White) and toured the Nevatim Air Force base in southern Israel. After their meeting, Netanyahu and Austin gave a joint press briefing. Netanyahu warned that Iran is continuing its efforts to achieve nuclear weapons - and to annihilate Israel. “You just said a moment ago in our meeting that we’re not just allies, we’re family. We call that ‘mishpacha’," said Netanyahu. "There is so much truth in that statement that our peoples instinctively understand.” “As you know the US-Israel defense partnership has continually expanded over successive administrations. Our cooperation is crucial for dealing with the many threats confronting the United States and Israel – threats that you are very familiar with by your service in Iraq.” “In the Middle East, there is no threat that is more serious, more dangerous, more pressing than that posed by the fanatical regime in Iran. Iran continues to support terrorists around the world on five continents, threatening civilians everywhere. Iran has never given up its quest for nuclear weapons and the missiles to deliver them. And Iran consistently and outrageously calls for Israel’s annihilation and works towards that goal.”“We both know the importance of preventing war, and we both know that Iran must never possess nuclear weapons.”“I will never allow Iran to obtain the nuclear capability of carrying out its genocidal goal of eliminating Israel. Israel will continue to defend itself against Iran’s aggression and terrorism.” After Netanyahu's comments, Secretary of Defense Austin "reaffirmed America's strong commitment to Israel," saying he had pushed for an in-person meeting with Netanyahu early in the Biden administration's term. "I also want to underscore my personal pledge to strengthening Israel's security and ensuring Israel's qualitative military edge. The close and strong ties that we enjoy with Israel are central to regional security in the Middle East.""We discussed ways to deepen and expand our long-standing defense relationship in the face of regional threats and other security challenges."
 

Statement from Minister Garneau to announce the cancellation of export permits to Turkey
April 12, 2021 – Ottawa, Ontario – Global Affairs Canada
The Honourable Marc Garneau, Minister of Foreign Affairs today issued the following statement:​
“Last fall, in line with our robust export control regime, the Government of Canada suspended export permits for military goods and technology to Turkey pending the results of an investigation into allegations that Canadian technology was being used by Azerbaijan in the military conflict in Nagorno-Karabakh.
“Those suspensions followed the decision to suspend the issuance of new export permits to Turkey in the fall of 2019, following its military incursion into northeastern Syria.
“Global Affairs Canada, in consultation with the Department of National Defence, has since conducted a thorough review of all suspended and valid export permits for all military goods and technology destined to Turkey.
“Following this review, which found credible evidence that Canadian technology exported to Turkey was used in Nagorno-Karabakh, today I am announcing the cancellation of permits that were suspended in the fall of 2020.
“This use was not consistent with Canadian foreign policy, nor end-use assurances given by Turkey.
“This morning, I spoke with Mevlüt Çavuşoğlu, Turkey’s Minister of Foreign Affairs, to reiterate Canada’s concern and to initiate a dialogue mechanism between Canadian and Turkish officials to build mutual confidence and greater cooperation on export permits to ensure consistency with end-use assurances before any further permits for military goods and technology (Group 2) are issued.
“Turkey is an important NATO ally and applications related to NATO cooperation programs will be assessed on a case-by-case basis.“
Associated link
Final Report – Review of Export Permits to Turkey
Contacts
Syrine Khoury
Press Secretary
Office of the Minister of Foreign Affairs
Syrine.Khoury@international.gc.ca

 

In Egypt, Russian top diplomat discusses trade, regional issues
The Arab Weekly/April 12/2021
CAIRO--The foreign ministers of Egypt and Russia discussed trade and other ties between the two nations Monday, with Egypt’s top diplomat urging Moscow to help settle Egypt’s dispute with Ethiopia over a massive dam project. Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov arrived in Cairo on Sunday for a two-day visit. He met Monday with President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi before his talks with Foreign Minister Sameh Shoukry. In a joint news conference with Shoukry, Lavrov said they discussed the implementation of joint mega projects, the most important of them a four-reactor power plant that a Russian firm is building in Egypt and a Russian industrial zone in the Suez Canal area. The two ministers said they also discussed regional conflicts in Libya, Syria and the Israeli-Palestinian cause along with the political stalemate in Lebanon. They discussed a massive dam Ethiopia is building on the Nile River’s main tributary, which Egypt and Sudan deem a major threat if it is filled and operated without a legally binding agreement. “We also rely on Russia … to push parties to refrain from unilateral actions,” Shoukry said, referring to Ethiopia’s plans to start a second crucial stage of the dam’s filling during this year’s rainy season.
Lavrov said Russia was not invited to engage in the talks between Egypt, Sudan and Ethiopia, but has supported an African Union-led settlement to the years-long dispute. The Russian minister did not speak about when Moscow would resume direct flights to Egypt’s Red Sea resorts. However, he told Egypt’s state-run Ahram daily in an interview published Monday that he expected the flights would be resumed “soon.”
Air links were suspended when the Islamic State group downed a Russian airliner over Egypt’s Sinai Peninsula in 2015, killing all 224 people on board. Egypt has since spent millions of dollars to upgrade security at its airports and undergone numerous checks by Russian experts. The suspension of Russian flights dealt a devastating blow to Egypt’s vital tourism industry, which had already been badly hit by the turmoil following a 2011 uprising. Russia-Egypt ties have deepened in recent years. Cairo’s relations with the US suffered a blow in 2013 when the Obama administration criticised the military overthrow of Egypt’s first freely-elected leader amid mass protests against his rule. In 2017, Egypt and Russia struck deals that allowed Cairo to buy billions of dollars’ worth of Russian weapons, including fighter jets and assault helicopters. They also signed a deal to have a Russian company build a nuclear reactor after Cairo agreed in principle to borrow $25 billion, or roughly 80% of the reactor’s cost, from Russia.

 

Public trial looms for Prince Hamzah on charges of conspiring against the king

The Arab Weekly/April 12/2021
AMMAN – New signs have emerged signalling that Jordan’s King Abdullah II is pushing towards a public trial for his half-brother Prince Hamzah on charges of “conspiracy” to topple the regime. These come more than a week after the most recent statements by the former crown prince.
The dispute between the king and the prince sparked a crisis that quickly came into the open. It included criticism by the prince of royal “misrule”, followed by news of “family reconciliation”, then by a message from the Jordanian monarch to his citizens, four days ago, in which he said that “Hamzah is in his palace and under my care.”Since then, it has been presumed that Prince Hamzah was under house arrest, in the light of the concerns expressed by his mother, Queen Noor Al-Hussein, about the conditions of his residence and statements by the United Nations that the prince could be under “de facto home arrest.”
Prince Hamzah is widely popular among the tribes and the outlying provinces. His criticisms have found an echo within the Jordanian protest movement, as it clamours for radical political reforms and an end to corruption. On Sunday, however, government circles indicated that Prince Hamzah had intentionally sought to overthrow the ruling system and that his trial and perhaps his imprisonment is only a matter of time.
Jordanian writer Fahad Al-Khaitan, who is close to the ruling establishment, published an article in which he wrote, “It was initially believed that the symbols of sedition worked to use the prince to achieve their goals, but intelligence gathered during a period of months has clearly indicated a different role for the prince, and his full involvement in preparations for Zero Hour”. The article which appeared in Al-Ghad daily newspaper on Sunday was couched in an unusually hostile tone against a member of the Hashemite family. Khaitan said, “Illusions reached a level of insanity as the prince listed his taking command of the army and supervision of the security services as his conditions to stop his anti-government activities, in blatant defiance of clear and explicit constitutional provisions”. Khaitan’s article coincided with information published by The New York Times, which quoted its own sources as confirming the prince’s demand, which was rejected by the king. Khaitan, who is the chairman of the government-financed Kingdom TV, said that Prince Hamzah, ” was keen on sending the audio recording outside the country, immediately after the meeting, hence showing little respect for his own Hashemite stature, or for being a former officer of the Arab Army.”The particular aspect of the “conspiracy” that raised most questions among the public was the supposed and hitherto improbable relationship between Prince Hamzah and the former head of the royal court, Basem Awadallah.
In this regard, Khaitan commented, “The facts will reveal how interests, ambitions and illusions can bring the two parties together.”Prince Hamzah and Awadallah have divergent views about various issues, such as the role of the government in the economy, the influence of clans in the system of government, the Palestinian issue and the consequences of the settlement of this issue on Jordan. Although Prince Hamzah appeared on Sunday in pictures with the royal family during a visit to the Hashemite shrines marking the 100th anniversary of the founding of Jordan, the government has not commented on questions that have arisen since last week about his current treatment. On Friday, the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights of the United Nations described the accusations against the prince as “broad,” expressing “concern at the lack of transparency around these arrests and detentions.”,” which affected 16 people, including some who are close to Prince Hamzah.
A spokesperson for the UN office said: “We are aware that there is an ongoing investigation but still it’s not clear to us if following the mediation on April 5, Prince Hamzah is still under de facto house arrest or not.” The office was referring to the reconciliation bid carried out by Prince Hassan bin Talal within the palace after a letter of loyalty to the king was signed by Prince Hamzah and before the royal address to the Jordanians, where the king offered his first comments on the crisis and said that ,“the next steps will be determined by the standard that governs all our decisions; the interest of the homeland and the interest of our loyal people”.But current talk about a “zero hour” for a coup against the regime means that army officers were involved in the supposed plot, which the government had denied from the beginning, saying that there were no soldiers among the detainees. If Prince Hamzah is to be tried on charges of planning a coup, this will require full disclosure of the facts including clarification of the nature of the plot to seize power and the relationships between those involved in the conspiracy. Queen Noor, who lives in the United States, criticised the government statements. She described the accusations directed against her son and the detainees as “wicked slander” and shared the hashtag #Where_is_Prince_Hamzah, which was widely shared on Jordanian social media. On her Twitter page, the widow of the late King Hussein bin Talal posted on Friday the statements of the Commissioner for Human Rights about the detainees, and she tweeted the same day that the suppression of protests in Myanmar is “a practice that seems to be common these days.” The protest movement that resurfaced in Jordan last month was dispersed by security forces as soon as it erupted in major cities. The upheaval took on greater momentum after the publication of accusations against Prince Hamzah, who enjoys wide popularity within the movement. Sources and local media accounts said that Prince Hamzah’s name was chanted in some of the protests. Hamzah, who was crown prince for five years that ended in 2004, has in one of his videos called for an end to “corruption” and “devastation” in the kingdom. The removal of Prince Hamzah as crown prince is seen as one of the main drivers of the current crisis.


Turkey, Libya Renew Commitment to 2019 Maritime Deal
Agence France Presse/April 12/2021
Turkey and Libya on Monday renewed their commitment to a controversial maritime deal signed in 2019, as Libyan Prime Minister Abdulhamid Dbeibah paid his first official visit to Ankara. Dbeibah was selected earlier this year through a U.N.-backed inter-Libyan dialogue to lead the country to national elections in December 2021. His government replaces two rival administrations based in Tripoli and the country's east, the latter loyal to military strongman Khalifa Hafter, whose forces tried but failed to seize the capital in a 2019-20 offensive. Under the 2019 deal agreed by Ankara and the Tripoli-based Government of National Accord (GNA), Turkey claimed greater rights over vast areas of the Mediterranean but was challenged by other countries including Greece. "Regarding the agreements signed by our countries, especially the maritime deal, we reaffirm that those agreements are valid," Dbeibah said after talks with Erdogan. The Turkish leader said the 2019 deal "secured the national interests and future of the two countries". "Today we reaffirmed our commitment to this matter," Erdogan said. The two leaders also signed a series of agreements before a press conference in the capital. The Libyan premier said Turkish companies would play "an important role in Libya's reconstruction given their long experience when it comes to working in Libya". Dbeibah added that the two countries will soon work towards "a free trade agreement". Turkey and the GNA had signed a military agreement alongside the maritime boundary deal which gave Ankara more rights to explore energy in the Mediterranean in November 2019. Ankara's military backing to the GNA during an offensive by Haftar helped turn the tide of the war in favor of Tripoli. Erdogan said Monday that Turkey would strengthen "solidarity and cooperation" with Libya. "We will continue to give all kinds of support to the Government of National Accord as we did for the previous legitimate government," the Turkish leader added. He said that from Tuesday, Turkey would provide Libya with 150,000 coronavirus vaccine doses, without offering further details. Libya has been mired in conflict since the 2011 NATO-backed uprising that toppled and killed veteran dictator Moammar Gadhafi. But in October last year the two sides signed a truce before a U.N.-led process saw a new transitional government installed in February.

 

Germany Demands Syria be Held Accountable over Chemical Arms
Agence France Presse/April 12/2021
Germany's Foreign Minister Heiko Maas on Monday demanded Syria's government be held accountable after an investigation from a global watchdog said the regime used the chemical weapon chlorine in a 2018 attack. "For us, it is clear that such an obvious violation of international law cannot remain without consequences," Maas said in a statement following the release of the report by the Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons (OPCW). "Those responsible must be held accountable." The watchdog accused the Syrian regime of using chlorine in an attack on the town of Saraqib. It is the second report by an investigations team set up by the OPCW, which has the new power to apportion blame for attacks. OPCW investigators interviewed 30 witnesses, analyzed samples collected at the scene, reviewed symptoms reported by victims and medical staff and examined satellite imagery to reach their conclusions, the Hague-based organization said. OPCW states will vote later this month on whether to impose sanctions on Syria, including the suspension of its voting rights in the organization, over its failure to comply with its rules. "All OPCW member states are now called to respond to these continuing violations by Syria of the Chemical Weapons Convention," Maas said, urging governments to "use the available means within the framework of the Convention to enforce its respect". Syria has continued to deny the use of chemical weapons and insists it has handed over its weapons stockpiles under a 2013 agreement.

 

Yemen's Huthi Rebels Claim Strikes on Saudi Oil Plants
Agence France Presse/April 12/2021
Yemen's Huthis claimed Monday to have launched drone strikes against Saudi energy giant Aramco's facilities, amid an upsurge in fighting between the insurgents and the Riyadh-backed government in northern Yemen. Neither Aramco or Saudi authorities immediately reported any attack.
Huthi spokesman Yahya Saree said in a statement carried by the rebels' Al-Masirah television that the strikes took place overnight, in retaliation for the six-year military campaign led by Saudi Arabia in Yemen. He said the Huthis had targeted Aramco refineries in the western Saudi city of Jeddah and in Jubail in the east, with 10 drones launched at dawn. He also said the Huthis hit "sensitive military areas" in the southern cities of Khamis Mushait and Jizan, with five drones and two ballistic missiles. On Sunday, the coalition said it had intercepted and destroyed Huthi drones targeting Khamis Mushait and Jizan.
The Iran-aligned rebels have struck Aramco facilities in the past, underscoring the vulnerability of Saudi Arabia's expensive and strategically vital oil infrastructure. Last November, the rebels hit an Aramco plant in Jeddah with a Quds-2 missile, tearing a hole in an oil tank and triggering an explosion and fire, the company said. The rebels' latest claim comes a day after at least 70 pro-government and Huthi fighters were killed in fierce fighting for Yemen's strategic northern city of Marib. The Huthis have been trying to seize Marib, the capital of an oil-rich region and the government's last significant pocket of territory in the north, since February. Yemen's civil war pits the Iran-backed rebels against an internationally recognized government backed by a Saudi-led military coalition. The grinding conflict has claimed tens of thousands of lives and displaced millions, according to international organizations, sparking what the U.N. calls the world's worst humanitarian crisis.
 

Russian Prison Threatens to Force-Feed Navalny
Agence France Presse/April 12/2021
Russian prison officials are threatening to start force-feeding jailed Kremlin critic Alexei Navalny, his team said Monday, after he lost eight kilograms (18 pounds) since starting a hunger strike. "Seeing the seriousness of the hunger strike, the administration is threatening every day to start force-feeding," Navalny's team said in a post on his Twitter account. It reported that Navalny, who last week said he had a cough and fever, had been transferred back to the prison barracks from its infirmary. "They are still not allowing a doctor to see him," it said. The 44-year-old opposition politician now weighs just 77 kilograms (169 pounds), it said, down from 85 kilograms (187 pounds) when he started the hunger strike on March 31. Navalny, who is 189 centimeters (six feet two inches) tall, had already lost significant weight in prison before launching the hunger strike. He weighed 93 kilograms (205 pounds) when he entered the facility in February.  The anti-corruption campaigner, who barely survived a poisoning with nerve agent Novichok last August, began refusing food in protest at what he said was a lack of proper medical treatment in prison for severe back pain and numbness in his legs. President Vladimir Putin's best-known opponent, Navalny was arrested in mid-January when he returned to Russia from Germany, where he had been treated for the poisoning, and was sentenced to two and a half years in prison on old embezzlement charges in February. Members of his defense team, who visited him in his penal colony in the town of Pokrov 100 kilometers (60 miles) east of Moscow last week, said he was also losing sensation in his hands. Lawyer Olga Mikhailova said that an MRT scan had shown that Navalny has two herniated discs in his back, as well as a bulging disc.
'Innocent man tortured'-
On Monday, as Russians across the country were celebrating the 60th anniversary of Yuri Gagarin's historic first spaceflight, Navalny's team urged Russians not to forget the opposition politician's plight despite the large-scale commemorations. "Yes, Cosmonautics Day is cool, of course," ally Lyubov Sobol tweeted. "But an innocent man is being tortured in front of the whole country right now." Navalny's lawyers and allies are demanding that he be transferred to a regular hospital. The Kremlin has said that Navalny is not entitled to any special treatment. Navalny has been a thorn in the Kremlin's side for a decade by probing corruption among officials and leading large protests throughout Russia supported by a regional network. His team has launched a new campaign seeking his release and announced plans to stage what they said would be "modern Russia's biggest protest." The team said they would set a date for the protest once 500,000 supporters had registered with a website. As of Monday, nearly 420,000 people had signed up. The team, which faces regular searches and arrests by law enforcement, also opened a new office in the North Caucasus republic of Dagestan on Sunday. But on Monday, the head of the regional network, Leonid Volkov, wrote on Twitter that "both of its employees have gone missing". Meanwhile, Navalny's personal doctor Anastasia Vasilyeva was fined 180,000 rubles ($2,325) for violating public order, lawyers from the Agora rights group representing her said Monday. Vasilyeva, who heads the Alliance of Doctors medical trade union which is critical of the government, had travelled to Navalny's penal colony last week to demand he receive proper medical treatment. She and eight other protesters were detained by police and last week a court handed week-long prison sentences to four of them.


One killed, police officer hurt in shooting at Knoxville, Tennessee high school
Reuters/April 12, 2021
One person was killed at a Knoxville, Tennessee high school on Monday and a police officer was wounded when police confronted an armed suspect. The shooting, which unfolded at about 3:15 p.m. local time at Austin-East Magnet School on the east side of Knoxville was the latest episode of gun violence in the United States since mid-March. Knoxville police said the officer struck by gunfire was expected to survive. “He is conscious and in good spirts. ... He’s going to be OK. I thanked him for putting his life on the line to protect sutdents and staff at the school. He said he’d rather be hurt than anybody else,” Knoxville Mayor Indya Kincannon told CBS News. Investigators did not immediately identify the suspect or slain victim except to say that they were both male. It was not immediately clear if either victim attended Austin-East Magnet School. “Based on the preliminary investigation, Knoxville Police Department officers responded to Austin-East Magnet High School on the report of a male subject who was possibly armed in the school,” the police department said on Facebook.“Upon approach of the subject, shots were fired. A KPD officer was struck at least one time and transported to the (University of Tennessee) Medical Center with injuries that are not expected to be life-threatening. One male was pronounced deceased at the scene, while another was detained for further investigation.” The police department had initially reported “multiple gunshot victims” in the attack.“Knox County Schools is responding to a shooting that occurred this afternoon at Austin-East Magnet High School. We are gathering information about this tragic situation and will provide additional information as soon as possible,” Knoxville schools superintendent Bob Thomas said on Twitter. “The school building has been secured and students who were not involved in the incident have been released to their families,” Thomas said. Agents from the US Bureau of Alcohol Tobacco and Firearms were en route to the scene to assist other law enforcement agencies, the bureau’s Nashville office said on Twitter.Police established a reunification site for families of the students at the baseball field behind the high school. One mother who had been separated from her daughter was waiting elsewhere near the school and was relieved to receive a text message from her that she was safe. In other shootings since mid-March, a man opened fire at the cabinet-making plant in Texas where he worked last week, killing one person and wounding six others before he was arrested. Eight people were slain at Atlanta-area spas, 10 people at a supermarket in Boulder, Colorado, and four people, including a 9-year-old boy at a real estate office in Orange, California.

 

Canada cancels military export permits for Turkey after illegal transfers abroad
Joseph Haboush, Al Arabiya English/Published: 12 April ,2021
Canada ordered the cancellation of all permits that allowed exporting military goods to Turkey on Monday after a review found that Ankara illegally transferred Canadian technology to Azerbaijan during last year’s Nagorno-Karabakh conflict. The announcement was made by Canadian Foreign Minister Marc Garneau, who said that the Canadian technology exported to Turkey was “not consistent with Canadian foreign policy, nor end-use assurances given by Turkey.”“Following this review, which found credible evidence that Canadian technology exported to Turkey was used in Nagorno-Karabakh, today I am announcing the cancellation of permits that were suspended in the fall of 2020,” Garneau said. The Canadian official said he spoke with his Turkish counterpart on Monday morning to reiterate Canada’s concerns. Garneau said there needed to be mutual confidence and greater cooperation on export permits to “ensure consistency with end-use assurances before any further permits for military goods and technology are issued.” A report from the Canadian government said that new export permits to Turkey were temporarily suspended in October 2019 after concerns that a Turkish military incursion in northeastern Syria would roll back progress in the fight against ISIS. And from October to December 2020, Canada reviewed all of its suspended and valid export permits with Turkey. The review found that certain Canadian military goods and technology exported to Turkey were used in Nagorno-Karabakh, Libya and Syria. Drones, most notably the Bayraktar TB2 UAVs, were used against Armenia during the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict, the review said. These drones were equipped with Canadian sensors. Al Arabiya English previously reported that Israel was also equipping Azerbaijan with drones to fight Armenia during the conflict that pitted a predominantly Muslim Azerbaijan against Christian Armenia. Canada also asked Turkey to provide information on allegations that Canadian technology was used in Nagorno-Karabakh. “Turkey did not provide any such information,” Canada’s review of Turkey licenses read.
Separately, the Canadian government said Turkey had an “evolving relationship with the terrorist group Hayat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS), which controls, militarily and administratively, the majority of the Idlib pocket that remains outside of [the Syrian] regime control.”

The Latest LCCC English analysis & editorials from miscellaneous sources published on April 12-13/2021

U.S. willing to lift sanctions imposed on Iran by Trump that are ‘inconsistent’
Karen DeYoung, Loveday Morris, Simon Denyer and Kareem Fahim/The Washington Post/April 12/2021
The Biden administration has opened the door to lifting Trump-imposed sanctions against Iran that are "inconsistent" with the 2015 nuclear deal, and also those that prevent Iran from accessing broader economic benefits under the agreement, according to a senior State Department official.
The formulation, offered after a first round of indirect talks between Iran and the United States this week, is designed to break a roadblock between what Iran has demanded and what the administration is prepared to give for both to return to compliance with the accord.
The official described the talks as "businesslike" and the atmosphere as "very constructive." Discussions are expected to resume in the middle of next week.
At Iran's insistence, there was no direct communication between the Iranians and the U.S. delegation headed by special envoy Robert Malley. Messages were carried back and forth by other participants in the nuclear deal — Britain, Germany and France, as well as Russia and China.
"If they don't want to sit down with us, too bad for them," the official said. "It's just going to be harder for them to get what they want." The official briefed reporters on the talks on the condition of anonymity, under rules set by the State Department.
Iranian vessel was struck by explosion in Red Sea as nuclear talks began, Iran says
The official described the negotiations as "complicated," and said the initial round had centered on the specifics of what each side is prepared to do to return to compliance with the agreement, from which President Donald Trump withdrew three years ago.
"We did not submit a list. We exchanged ideas about the principles that would guide any sanctions on the U.S. side. Iran did not submit a list either," the official said. Since the U.S. withdrawal, Iran has increased the quantity and quality of its enriched uranium, far exceeding the limits imposed by the 2015 agreement. It has activated more-sophisticated centrifuges, all of which would have to be decommissioned and placed under verifiable seal.
But the situation is far more complicated for the United States.
While the original text lifted specific sanctions that had been imposed related to Iran's nuclear activity, it also broadly invited Iran back into the international economic community, so that it could trade and seek foreign investment without worry that the United States would threaten or impose sanctions on those conducting business with it.
Sanctions related to other aspects of Iran's behavior — alleged terrorism sponsorship, support of proxy wars and development of ballistic missiles — were not lifted by the original agreement, and not prohibited in the future.
But when Trump withdrew from the agreement, he not only reimposed all the sanctions that had originally been lifted but also added over 1,500 more. Many were not labeled as nuclear-related but as punishment for terrorism or other activities.
Included among them were Iran's Central Bank and other financial institutions, which were called terrorist entities. Trump administration officials were fairly open at the time that this was done to make it harder for a successor administration to simply return to the agreement by lifting "nuclear" sanctions.
"The United States retains the right to impose sanctions for nonnuclear reasons," the official said. "We've made clear, publicly, to the Iranians indirectly, our view is that all sanctions inconsistent with the [deal] and benefits that Iran expects" from the agreement, "we are prepared to lift if Iran comes back into compliance."
"That doesn't mean all of them," the official said of the existing sanctions, adding that "some" are "legitimate." But "our position is . . . consistent with plain language and any fair interpretation of the deal."
Talks on reviving Iran nuclear deal begin on ‘right track,’ Tehran envoy says
The administration has undergone what the official said was a "painstaking effort to determine which need to be lifted. . . . The label itself doesn't always give the answer. We have to keep in mind that there was a purposeful and self-avowed effort" by the previous administration "precisely with the political intent to make it hard for any successor that wanted to go back in to do so."
Iran's position heading into the new talks is that "all" sanctions imposed by Trump must be lifted before it will return to compliance. "If Iran sticks to the position that every sanction since 2017" must be removed, the talks will remain at an "impasse," the official said.
"All Trump sanctions were anti-JCPOA" and "must be removed," Iranian Foreign Minister Javad Zarif tweeted Friday, using the initials for the nuclear pact.
Iran also said Friday that it had released a South Korean ship seized three months ago and released its captain, easing at least one source of tension between Tehran and Washington.
Iranian forces intercepted the South Korean tanker in the Persian Gulf in January, alleging it was captured for “technical” reasons related to environmental pollution, while also complaining that Seoul had frozen $7 billion of its assets to comply with U.S. sanctions.
Iran denies its seizure of South Korean tanker is hostage-taking
It was unclear to what extent Iran’s move was linked to the talks in Vienna. But Iran’s demand for access to its frozen funds is part of broader negotiations over the revival of the nuclear deal between Tehran and six world powers.
Iran has in the past strongly hinted that access to its funds in South Korea might be the kind of goodwill gesture that would break the deadlock with the United States. The money would pass through Switzerland and be restricted to purchases of humanitarian goods such as medical devices, Iranian officials have said. A South Korean Foreign Ministry official said Friday that “we firmly expressed our willpower to solve issues related to the frozen funds.” The official, who was not authorized to be named, said South Korea’s “efforts were communicated to Iran and could have positively influenced the final decision to release the seized vessel.”
But the State Department, while saying it was “pleased” with release of the ship, said in a statement that “the United States has not authorized the release of the Iranian funds frozen under sanctions and being held in South Korean banks.”
The European Union, which is hosting the talks, said in a statement that Iran and the other signatories to the deal — excluding the United States — held formal meetings Friday that “took stock of the discussions held at various levels” over the past days. It said that European coordinators would continue separate contacts with all participants until they reconvene next week.
Morris reported from Berlin, Denyer from Tokyo and Fahim from Istanbul. Michael Birnbaum in St. Louis contributed to this report.

How Republicans Can Stop Biden from Lifting Iran Sanctions
Richard Goldberg/ National Review..FDD/April 12/2021
Instead of diluting their principles, congressional Republicans should use every available procedural tool to force tough votes.
President Joe Biden sent his negotiators to Vienna this week with a singular mission: Offer Iran billions of dollars as part of a first step toward rejoining a dangerous nuclear deal that Tehran cheated on from the very beginning. The only question now is what Congress plans to do to defend the sanctions architecture it has built over many years.
For weeks, Republicans and centrist Democrats in Washington held out hope that Biden would utilize the historic sanctions leverage he inherited from his predecessor to negotiate a better, more comprehensive deal with Iran. Biden had said that his goal was to “tighten and lengthen Iran’s nuclear constraints, as well as address the missile program.” Secretary of State Tony Blinken told the Senate Foreign Relations Committee that it would not be in the U.S. interest to lift terrorism sanctions on the Central Bank of Iran or the National Iranian Oil Company — institutions that were originally provided sanctions relief under the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA), as the 2015 nuclear deal is formally known.
Under the Biden administration’s reported offer, however, the U.S. would lift terrorism sanctions on Iran up front without requiring any halt to the regime’s state sponsorship of terrorism. Iran would gain access to billions of dollars through its central bank and national oil company — both of which are subject to sanctions because of their ties to terrorism and Iran’s Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), which itself is correctly designated as a terrorist entity. When asked this week if terrorism sanctions were, in fact, on the table in Vienna, State Department spokesperson Ned Price all but admitted it.
Under the arrangement being discussed, the Islamic Republic would gain tacit approval to sponsor terrorism, hold Americans hostage, enrich uranium on its own soil, test nuclear-capable missiles and engage in human-rights abuses against the Iranian people. More shockingly, a so-called nuclear deal to limit Iran’s ability to develop nuclear weapons would not require Tehran to account for its secret nuclear-weapons archive or clandestine nuclear sites, materials and activities currently under investigation by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA). Recall that Iran lied to the IAEA in 2015 to gain access to sanctions relief. Its continued deception should be at the heart of any negotiation over its nuclear program.
Effectively, Biden is offering to subsidize the IRGC and reward Iranian nuclear deceit if the mullahs merely stop enriching uranium at higher levels and stop testing advanced centrifuges — neither of which are truly concessions since the JCPOA allows Iran to do both over time. Moreover, the offer of terrorism-sanctions relief constitutes a material breach of trust by the secretary of state, who led senators to believe that would never happen if they voted to confirm him.
On a bipartisan basis, Congress should demand a vote on any agreement reached in Vienna before sanctions are lifted; indeed, the law requires nothing less. Under the Iran Nuclear Agreement and Review Act of 2015, the president must submit to Congress the text of any agreement reached with Iran over its nuclear program and allow Congress time to review and potentially vote to reject it.
Senators of both parties should also consider responding to Secretary Blinken’s broken commitment on terrorism sanctions by pushing legislation to prohibit any sanctions relief — waivers, licenses, or delistings — that directly or indirectly benefits entities subject to U.S. sanctions as of January 20, 2021, because of their connections to terrorism and the IRGC. Any terrorism sanctions suspended before the law takes effect should be reinstated as well. Such legislation could get tacked on as an amendment to the annual defense authorization bill, setting up a tough political vote for Democrats who voted for Iran terrorism sanctions four years ago — while the Trump administration was still in the Iran deal.
Another potential amendment: no sanctions relief for Iran until all American hostages are released and Iran fully accounts for its undeclared nuclear activities. Who supports rewarding Tehran for taking Americans hostage? Who will defend a nuclear deal that lets Iran continue hiding nuclear sites, materials, and activities — contradicting the entire premise of the agreement? Forcing votes on must-pass legislation that exposes the fallacies of the Biden administration’s Iran policy will dramatically turn up the pressure.
For those who think it’s hopeless, think again. The Obama administration opposed sanctions targeting the Central Bank of Iran back in 2011. Yet Republicans — then in the Senate minority — used Senate procedure to force a vote on those sanctions anyway, and they passed 100–0. The lesson learned for Republicans: Instead of diluting their principles on Iran, they should use every available procedural tool to force tough votes.
Finally, Republicans should make clear that they will swiftly reimpose any sanctions relief provided to Iran by the Biden administration if they retake control of Congress in 2022 or the White House in 2024. Representative Mike Gallagher (R.,Wisc.) and Senator Tom Cotton (R., Ark.) introduced resolutions in the House and Senate opposing any lifting of Iran sanctions. These resolutions send a message to companies and banks around the world that they will once again find themselves subject to U.S. sanctions in the future if they wade back into Iran at the Biden administration’s behest.
Republicans should stop President Biden from relieving sanctions on Iran. They should also give the private sector second thoughts about rushing to do business with the world’s leading state sponsor of terrorism — especially since any sanctions relief is certain to be temporary.
*Richard Goldberg is a senior adviser at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies. He was the lead Senate Republican negotiator for three rounds of sanctions against Iran and served as director for Countering Iranian Weapons of Mass Destruction on the National Security Council. Follow him on Twitter @rich_goldberg. FDD is a nonpartisan think tank focused on foreign policy and national security issues.
 

After Mossad report, Gantz calls for investigation into security leaks
Udi Shaham/Jerusalem Post/April 12/2021
"It harms our troops, our security, and the interest of the State of Israel, and I think that there should be a thorough investigation.”
Defense Minister Benny Gantz called on Monday for the immediate opening of an investigation to uncover who in Israel has been leaking classified details on Israeli operations to the media. Gantz sent the request to Attorney-General Avichai Mandelblit.
“I am not talking about a specific operation, but I do want to talk about the chatter issue,” Gantz told reporters on Monday. “It is a serious issue and I turned to the Shin Bet (Israel Security Agency) and the IDF’s Information Security Department to open an investigation into it. We can’t operate when everyone is babbling. We can’t accept these winkings and these ‘Western sources’ stories,” he said.
“It harms our troops, our security, and the interest of the State of Israel, and I think that there should be a thorough investigation,” Gantz said. The Defense Ministry later said that Gantz also sent the request to Mandelblit.
Gantz’s call for a probe came a day after “Western sources” – widely assumed to be Israeli – were quoted in the media saying that the Mossad was behind the cyberattack at Natanz, which caused extensive damage to Iran’s main uranium enrichment facility. It was also less than a week after reports that the Israeli Navy was behind an attack against Iran’s IRGC Saviz vessel in the Red Sea.
Asked if the cabinet changed Israel’s policy of ambiguity regarding top-secret operations, Gantz said that “there was no discussion about it. I think that it is irresponsible behavior – and if it comes from personal or political interests, it is even worse.
“I don’t know where it comes from,” he added, “but I know where it is not coming from. I know that the prime minister has great experience in the diplomatic-security field, and am not belittling it. I think that all other consideration should be pushed aside, and I hope that this is what he is doing.”
On Monday Gantz and US Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin visited Nevatim Air Force Base – the home of the IAF’s F35 squadrons – and the secretary was briefed by IAF commander Maj.-Gen. Amikam Norkin.
The secretary was presented with new developments, cutting edge technologies and systems, including new innovations on the F35, the Iron Dome missile defense system recently acquired by the United States, the Arrow anti-ballistic missile, David’s Sling and the Trophy military active protection system, among others. Gantz later said that the visit should not be taken for granted, and that it illustrated the deep friendship between the two countries. “I have a years-long acquaintance with Secretary Austin, and his visit also shows the importance of the security relations of the countries, and how the Biden administration sees them.”The defense minister said that the duo discussed Israel’s strategic challenges, including the JCPOA, the Iranian entrenchment efforts throughout the Middle East, normalization with Arab countries, the conflict with the Palestinians, the need to strengthen ties with Jordan and Egypt, and Chinese activity in the region.“We talked about how we see the right nuclear agreement, and the way it should be treated,” Gantz said. “We believe that the old agreement isn’t good enough, and the pressure on Iran should be kept. And that an agreement – without an expiration date and with the proper ability to oversee it – should be reached. “We found a listening ear, and there’s an American commitment to cooperate, even if we don’t always agree 100% on all different topics,” he added.
Gantz also said that Austin received a presentation on the way Hezbollah and Hamas build their power and their combat doctrine – and that one of its essential foundations is operating from densely populated areas.
“[We talked about] the implications of this topic on the ICC trial,” Gantz said. “The Americans support us on this issue.”


Indoctrinated in Hate: ‘This Is the Start of the New Caliphate’

Raymond Ibrahim/Gatestone Institute/April 12/2021
While boys in the West are all but indoctrinated into becoming girls—if not surgically mutilated, at least spiritually emasculated—boys in the Muslim world are increasingly indoctrinated into becoming super jihadis: ISIS 2.0.
The news is coming in fast from a variety of sources.
A documentary filmmaker, Alan Duncan, for instance, recently made a brief video of his visit to al-Hawl refugee camp in northeastern Syria, run by the Kurdish-led Syrian Democratic Forces. Although 80% of the camp consists of women and (27,000) children, many of whom had fled ISIS, the camp is known as the “Womb of ISIS.” In the video, highlighted in a February 2021 report, eight to ten year old boys appear raising one finger—symbolic of jihad. When asked about the gesture, one boy responded: “This means the Islamic State remains.” On being asked if they want to be doctors or teachers when they grow up, one boy says, “We don’t want to be a doctor. We want to be a brother fighter. We want to fight the apostates.” Then a woman, dressed in a black burka, declares that she wants the children to become “mujahidin who fight in the way Allah”—who “fight the infidels.” According to Duncan, the reason for all this indoctrination is that
There are already training camps in there—they are training the ISIS ideologies to the kids. They are not teaching them A, B and C—they are teaching them to hate. To hate the West …. They are training them for future jihad…. The children are victims of ISIS and their parents. They are within an extremist Islamic-controlled camp. They are not being told how to become doctors and nurses—the little girls are there to serve and breed. The boys are there to be the future fighters and the future suicide bombers…. This is the start of the new caliphate. I am certain of it. You can sense the fear in there of the religious police. They are trying to keep the structure of caliphate in there—the laws, the punishment. It’s like walking in the caliphate. It’s like walking into another world.
A camp official agreed, adding that “The women and children are radicalized—the vehicles of the humanitarian workers are even attacked with stones. The guards do feel unsafe while patrolling the camp. However, they are armed and trained.”
Similarly, in Nigeria, Islamic terrorists released a 17-minute video of children undergoing “religious education and indoctrination sessions.” According to a February 28, 2021 report,
The dreaded Boko Haram terrorists have released a video where children as young as 10-years-old were seen being trained in the art of combat and insurgency in what it tagged ‘Next Generation Fighters’. In the alleged training video, the child soldiers are seen being trained with sophisticated weapons like AK-47 rifles and Zastava M21, a very powerful weapon… The images from the video show the relatively young children dressed in combat-style clothing and balaclava participating in martial arts training, weapon handling training and religious education class….
Hate-filled indoctrination and training in violence is not limited to the “schools” of ISIS or Boko Haram. Public schools all around the Muslim world share elements of this indoctrination. Most recently, a March 2021 study exposed how the school curriculum of Turkey—for decades one of the Muslim world’s most secular nations—is also increasingly full of jihadi propaganda. Some of the report’s “main findings” follow:
The Turkish curriculum has been significantly radicalized in recent years. Jihad war is introduced as a central value; martyrdom in battle is glorified. Islam is depicted as political, using science and technology to advance its goals. An ethno-nationalist religious vision combining neo-Ottomanism and pan-Turkism is taught. Concepts such as “Turkish World Domination” and Turkish or Ottoman “Ideal of the World Order” are emphasized. The curriculum adopts an anti-American stance and displays sympathy toward the motivations of ISIS and Al-Qaeda. There are anti-Armenian and pro-Azerbaijani stances. … Subtle anti-democratic messaging is conveyed (e.g., Gezi Park protests). Christians and Jews are characterized as infidels instead of People of the Book. The curriculum demonizes Zionism and verges on anti-Semitic…
Even in the West, Muslim children are being “virtually” indoctrinated online, including during the COVID-19 pandemic. According to a March 4, 2021 report (updated Mar. 10), “Children are being exposed to ISIS terrorism online during lockdown, raising fears of brainwashing, the British foreign secretary said.” Dominic Raab told Parliament that this rise “of violent internet indoctrination” is occurring at a “critical moment,” when there has been a 7 percent increase in the amount of terrorist propaganda appearing last year.
“This is because terrorists have digital access to those who are probably the most susceptible to extremist narratives,” Raab added. “And we can see a worrying rise in the proportion of children and teenagers that are now being arrested for terrorism offences.” He referred to the mixture of “bored youths stuck indoors during lockdown,” where they are “subjected to extremist propaganda online,” as the “perfect storm.”
There is another factor to add into the mix: all of this unprecedented radicalization of Muslim youth in jihadi hate and violence is occurring at a time when boys in the West are being unprecedentedly indoctrinated into renouncing masculinity and embracing effeminacy. What will happen in a few decades when all these boys—those raised on absolute hate and violence and those raised on absolute tolerance and nonviolence—become the world’s decision makers?

Palestinian Elections: What the Biden Administration Does Not Want to Know
Khaled Abu Toameh/Gatestone Institute/April 12, 2021
Hamas and the PFLP have rejected all the agreements signed between Israel and the PLO, including the Oslo Accords. Yet, these terrorist groups have no problem running in an election held under the umbrella of the Oslo Accords.
[I]t is already evident that some of them have no intention of complying with the wishes of the State Department about "renouncing violence and terrorism" or accepting the "two-state solution."
Representatives of some of the lists running in the election, in fact, are promising the exact opposite. They are saying that they are committed to continuing the fight against Israel and have absolutely no intention of recognizing Israel's right to exist.
These Palestinians oppose any recognition of Israel's right to exist; they oppose any form of normalization with Israel; they oppose any peace talks with Israel and have repeatedly denounced any peace process with Israel as an act of treason.
Abu Zuhri and the Hamas leadership are sending the following message to the State Department spokesman: If you think Hamas will renounce violence and terrorism or accept the so-called two-state solution, you are sadly deluding yourself.
This dangerous exploitation of the Oslo Accords, however, does not seem to bother the US administration or the European Union when they talk about the need for the Palestinians to have free and democratic elections.
Like Hamas, the PFLP also vowed to pursue the fight against Israel "until the liberation of all of Palestine" -- in other words, all of Israel.
Under the current circumstances, it seems that Palestinians who support terrorism and do not accept the "two-state solution" are headed toward dominating the next Palestinian parliament and government.
Now that the Hamas and the PFLP candidates have been approved by the Central Elections Commission, the US or the rest of the international community can prevent this plot from materializing by making it clear that they will not recognize any future Palestinian government with terrorists. This demand should be made before, not after the elections.
Hamas and the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine have rejected all the agreements signed between Israel and the PLO, including the Oslo Accords. Yet, these terrorist groups have no problem running in an election held under the umbrella of the Oslo Accords. Pictured: Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh votes in the Palestinian legislative election on January 25, 2006, in Gaza City.
During a press briefing on April 1, US State Department Spokesperson Ned Price talked about the upcoming Palestinian elections and the "two-state solution." On the elections, the first in 15 years, Price said:
"The exercise of democratic elections is a matter for the Palestinian people to determine. We note that the US and other key partners in the international community have long been clear about the importance of participants in that democratic process, renouncing violence and renouncing terrorism, recognizing Israel's right to exist."
On recognizing Israel's right to exist, Price said:
"The two-state solution is precisely what will allow Israelis and Palestinians to live side by side in dignity and security, securing the interests – in the interests of Israelis, in the interests of Palestinians together. That's precisely why are we are supporting this two-state solution, just as previous administrations of both political stripes have."
Two days later, the Palestinian Central Elections Commission announced that 36 lists have submitted electoral slates for the parliamentary elections, scheduled for May 22.
Although the candidates have still not announced their political platforms, it is already evident that some of them have no intention of complying with the wishes of the State Department about "renouncing violence and terrorism" or accepting the "two-state solution."
Representatives of some of the lists running in the election, in fact, are promising the exact opposite. They are saying that they are committed to continuing the fight against Israel and have absolutely no intention of recognizing Israel's right to exist.
Two of those lists belong to Hamas, the Islamist movement ruling the Gaza Strip, and the PLO's Marxist-Leninist Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP).
The Hamas list, named "Jerusalem is Our Destiny," has been approved by the Palestinian Central Elections Commission, although the leaders of the Islamist movement say they do not recognize the Oslo Accord signed in 1993 between Israel and the PLO.
It is worth noting that the elections are being held in accordance with the 1995 Israel-Palestinian Interim Agreement (Oslo II), in which the two sides reaffirmed "their desire to achieve a just, lasting and comprehensive peace settlement and historic reconciliation."
Hamas and the PFLP have rejected all the agreements signed between Israel and the PLO, including the Oslo Accords. Yet, these terrorist groups have no problem running in an election held under the umbrella of the Oslo Accords.
In fact, Hamas and the PFLP seem to be using the Oslo Accords as a Trojan horse to try and take over the Palestinian parliament and government. The two groups are strongly opposed to any peace agreement with Israel and do not recognize Israel's right to exist. Hamas and the PFLP, however, have no problem using the Oslo Accords as a tool for participating in the elections.
The enemies of peace, in other words, are using a peace agreement to advance their goal of destroying the prospects of a peace process between the Palestinians and Israel.
The Palestinians who oppose peace with Israel have long demanded that the Palestinian leadership revoke all the agreements it signed with Israel.
These Palestinians oppose any recognition of Israel's right to exist; they oppose any form of normalization with Israel; they oppose any peace talks with Israel and have repeatedly denounced any peace process with Israel as an act of treason.
This dangerous exploitation of the Oslo Accords, however, does not seem to bother the US administration or the European Union when they talk about the need for the Palestinians to have free and democratic elections.
The leaders of Hamas and PFLP, meanwhile, are unambiguous about their intentions.
Sami Abu Zuhri, a spokesperson for Hamas, said that his group chose the name "Jerusalem is Our Destiny" to drive home the point that the officially designated terrorist group to which he belongs has not changed its policies toward the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, especially the refusal to accept Israel's right to exist and the desire to replace it with an Islamic state.
"This list proves that Hamas's convictions and policies have not changed," Abu Zuhri said. "Hamas fully believes that its true destination is toward Jerusalem and that soon there will be a decisive battle to defeat [Israel] and it expel it from our land."
According to Abu Zuhri, Hamas is running in the election to "prepare, with all strength, for the battle of Jerusalem."
When Abu Zuhri talks about "expelling Israel from our land," he is reaffirming Hamas's commitment to its charter, which states:
"... the land of Palestine has been an Islamic Waqf throughout the generations and until the Day of Resurrection; no one can renounce it or part of it. There is no solution to the Palestinian problem except by Jihad [holy war]. We must spread the spirit of Jihad among the Islamic Umma, clash with the enemies and join the ranks of the Jihad fighters."
The Hamas official is openly admitting that his group is running in the election partly to wage war on Israel.
Needless to say, Abu Zuhri and the Hamas leadership are sending the following message to the State Department spokesman: If you think Hamas will renounce violence and terrorism or accept the so-called two-state solution, you are sadly deluding yourself.
Palestinian researcher Walid Khaled has pointed out that the Hamas electoral list includes several terrorists who are "heroic prisoners and symbols of Jihad for this great people."
The Hamas terrorists held in Israeli prisons, Khaled announced, "are the model that generations adore, and families raise their children to emulate and follow them."
As to why Hamas chose to name its electoral list after Jerusalem, Khaled said: "Jerusalem is our destiny because there are no half-solutions with this entity [Israel]; it is neither a neighbor nor a partner, but an enemy."
Another Hamas official, Fawzi Barhoum, also acknowledged that his group was in the election to launch a war on Israel: "We will continue our struggle and resistance until the liberation of Palestine, Jerusalem and Al-Aqsa Mosque."
Similarly, the PFLP, whose representatives are running in the election under the slogan "Beat of the People," has also made it clear that it is planning to use the Oslo Accords as a Trojan horse to destroy the same accords. Explaining its decision to contest the elections, the PFLP said:
"The Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine continues its categorical rejection of the Oslo Accords and demands that the Palestinian Authority cancel this agreement and sever its relations with [Israel]. We categorically refuse to recognize the Zionist entity."
Like Hamas, the PFLP also vowed to pursue the fight against Israel "until the liberation of all of Palestine" -- in other words, all of Israel.
In light of the schism and internal squabbling in Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas's ruling Fatah faction, which is running in the election under three different lists, groups such as Hamas and the PFLP, if and when the vote takes place, are short-listed to gain numerous seats in the Palestinian parliament. Such a victory would easily enable the two groups to become part of a new government coalition.
Under the current circumstances, it seems that Palestinians who support terrorism and do not accept the "two-state solution" are headed toward dominating the next Palestinian parliament and government.
The US and the rest of the international community are still capable of making one important move in this dangerous sequence of events: consider how their turning a blind eye to the participation of extremist anti-peace groups in the election contributed to the emerging nightmare scenario.
Now that the Hamas and the PFLP candidates have been approved by the Central Elections Commission, the US or the rest of the international community can prevent this plot from materializing by making it clear that they will not recognize any future Palestinian government with terrorists. This demand should be made before, not after the elections.
*Khaled Abu Toameh is an award-winning journalist based in Jerusalem.
© 2021 Gatestone Institute. All rights reserved. The articles printed here do not necessarily reflect the views of the Editors or of Gatestone Institute. No part of the Gatestone website or any of its contents may be reproduced, copied or modified, without the prior written consent of Gatestone Institute.