English LCCC Newsbulletin For
Lebanese, Lebanese Related, Global News & Editorials
For July 21/2020
Compiled & Prepared by: Elias Bejjani
The Bulletin's Link on the lccc Site
http://data.eliasbejjaninews.com/eliasnews19/english.july21.20.htm
News Bulletin Achieves Since
2006
Click Here to enter the LCCC Arabic/English news bulletins Achieves since 2006
Bible Quotations For today
Jesus Stresses the Importance Of persistence
in life
Luke 11/05-08: “And he said to them, ‘Suppose one of you has a
friend, and you go to him at midnight and say to him, “Friend, lend me three
loaves of bread; for a friend of mine has arrived, and I have nothing to set
before him.” And he answers from within, “Do not bother me; the door has already
been locked, and my children are with me in bed; I cannot get up and give you
anything.”I tell you, even though he will not get up and give him anything
because he is his friend, at least because of his persistence he will get up and
give him whatever he needs.”
Titles For The Latest English LCCC
Lebanese & Lebanese Related News & Editorials published on July 20-21/2020
Ministry of Health: 46 new coronavirus infections
46 New COVID-19 Cases in Lebanon
MoPH: 3 coronavirus cases among returnees on 18/7/2020
IAEA grants Lebanon two PCR testing laboratories
Health Minister chairs meeting over stricter measures to curb coronavirus spread
Young Lebanese Doctor Dies of COVID-19
Abdel Samad: May the soul of Lebanon's angel Dr. Loai Ismail rest in peace
Baabda Palace witnesses array of political, diplomatic, and university meetings
Al-Rahi Urges Unity to Reach 'U.N. Resolution' on Lebanon Neutrality
Ibrahim from Center House: Hariri is keen on Lebanon, its stability and
prosperity
Judge Orders Preventive Assets Freeze of Central Bank Governor
Ghajar Says Power Cuts to Ease before Midweek
Security Sources: Lebanese Detained in Cyprus Not Linked to Hizbullah
Fahmi Launches Awareness Campaign over COVID-19
Diab chairs meeting of ministerial committee for the follow-up of waste file
Diab cables Sisi congratulating him on July 23 revolution commemoration
Diab meets military charter group delegation, Secretary General of
Lebanese-Syrian Supreme Council
Hariri receives Tarraf
Transfer of authority of Spanish brigade
Bukhari receives phone call from Berri checking on Saudi Monarch's health
Minister of Information broaches role of media with World Bank advisor, Modern
University delegation
ICMP welcomes appointment of members of Lebanon National Commission for the
Missing and Forcibly Disappeared
AUB President Dr. Fadlo Khuri addressees AUB Community
Bassil muddles Lebanese debate on neutrality, provokes Palestinian pushback
Qatar's Hezbollah funding exposed by whistle-blower contractor/Damien
McElroy/The National/July 20/2020
Titles For The Latest English LCCC
Miscellaneous Reports And News published on July 20-21/2020
Syria Reports Israeli Air Raids on Capital/Associated Press
Iran executes man convicted of spying for CIA, Mossad
Iran increasingly obsessed with China deal, blames Israel for controversy
Statement from International Coordination and Response Group for the victims of
Flight PS752 on Iran delivering flight recorders
Tehran pressures Kadhimi with accusations of involvement in Soleimani’s
assassination
UAE's Amal Spacecraft Rockets toward Mars in Arab World 1st
Turkey Urges 'Immediate' End to Haftar Support in Libya
Arbil Denies Handing Syria Kurd Official's Niece to Turkey
Top Democrats 'Gravely Concerned' over Foreign Interference in U.S. Election
Israel Probes Palestinian Jerusalem Governor over 'Terrorism'
Egypt Parliament Greenlights Possible Intervention in Libya
Troubled Trump to Relaunch His Coronavirus Briefings
Titles For The Latest LCCC English analysis & editorials from miscellaneous sources published on July 20-21/2020
Remembering the AMIA Bombing: Why It Matters 26 Years
Later/Toby Dershowitz/FDD/July 20/2020
Tehran Consolidates Hardline Gains At Home While COVID-19 Spreads/Behnam Ben
Taleblu and Saeed Ghasseminejad/Radio Farda/July 20/2020
Turkey’s Bar Associations Become the Latest Target of Erdogan’s Iran-Inspired
“Reform”/Aykan Erdemir and Philip Kowalski/Policy Brief/July 20/2020
Why last weekend’s G20 meeting of finance ministers and central bank governors
mattered/Cornelia Meyer/Arab News/July 21, 2020
Egypt’s strong military message to Turkey, Tunisia/Dr. Abdellatif El-Menawy/Arab
News/July 21, 2020
UN reform essential but unlikely to happen/Chris Doyle/Arab News/July 21, 2020
The Latest English LCCC Lebanese & Lebanese Related News & Editorials published on July 20-21/2020
Ministry of Health: 46 new coronavirus infections
NNA/July 21, 2020
The Ministry of Public Health announced on Monday 46 new coronavirus infections,
which raised the cumulative number of confirmed cases to 2,905.
28 cases were locally detected and 18 among returnees.
46 New COVID-19 Cases in Lebanon
Naharnet/July 20/2020
Twenty-eight residents and 18 expats tested positive for COVID-19 over the past
24 hours, the Health Ministry said on Monday. One more fatality was also
recorded, raising the death toll to 41, while the new cases raise the country’s
overall tally to 2,905 -- among them 2,100 local cases and 1,562 recoveries.
Twelve of the local cases were recorded in Baabda district, seven in Beirut, two
in Tyre district and one in each of Monteverde, Mayrouba, Bijjeh, Jdeidet
Mijdlaya, Chtaura, al-Saksakiyeh and Kfarfila.
MoPH: 3 coronavirus cases among returnees on 18/7/2020
NNA/July 21, 2020
The Ministry of Public Health on Friday announced the results of PCR tests that
were conducted on July 18, 2020, at Beirut airport. According to the Ministry,
one passenger aboard a flight arriving from Brussels, one aboard a flight
arriving from Riyadh, and one aboard a flight arriving from Doha, have tested
positive for the novel coronavirus. It is to note that all the other flights
that arrived in Beirut on that day were found virus-free.
IAEA grants Lebanon two PCR testing laboratories
NNA/July 21, 2020
The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) will grant Lebanon two
fully-equipped PCR laboratories to be delivered to Hariri Governmental
University Hospital, and the Military Hospital, under the auspices of Minister
of Public Health Dr. Hamad Hassan. The announcement was made following a meeting
on Monday at Hassan’s office with Director General of the Lebanese Atomic Energy
authority, Dr. Bilal Nassouli, and other concerned officials. For his part,
Hassan said that the grant falls within the framework of cooperation between
Lebanese institutions and departments to achieve the most ideal goal in
protecting the society from the Coronavirus pandemic, “whether at the extreme
peak of the first wave or later in the second wave." “The laboratory to be
provided to Hariri Hospital will raise its capacity to conduct two hundred PCR
tests daily; this grant comes in a timely manner in line with the increasing
number of Covid-19 patients, the increasing number of visitors from abroad
arriving in the country through Rafic Hariri International Airport, as well as
the increasing field checks by the Ministry of Health,” Hassan said.
Health Minister chairs meeting over stricter measures to curb coronavirus spread
NNA/July 21, 2020
Minister of Public Health, Hamad Hassan, on Monday indicated that Lebanon has
entered a critical stage as it stands on the threshold of the Covid-19 local
spread phase. Hassan added that those who fail to abide by isolation terms could
face the possibility of being transferred to a quarantine center. The Minister
made these remarks during a meeting he chaired at the Ministry of Public Health
to determine stricter measures to curb the community spread of coronavirus.
Young Lebanese Doctor Dies of COVID-19
Agence France Presse/Naharnet/July 20/2020
Lebanese physician Louay Ismail, 32, died Monday at the Nabih Berri state-run
hospital in Nabatieh due to COVID-19 complications, the National News Agency
said. Ismail, who hailed from the Tyre district town of al-Zalloutiyeh, had been
a shift doctor at the emergency room of the Lebanese Italian Hospital in Tyre.
“He showed coronavirus symptoms two weeks ago and underwent three PCR tests all
of which came out positive. He was quarantined for seven days before being
transferred four days ago to the Nabih Berri state-run hospital after suffering
severe pneumonia,” NNA added. “He underwent the applicable treatments there
before passing away,” the agency said. Ismail's death is Lebanon's first medical
sector fatality from the pandemic. Health Minister Hamad Hasan mourned the young
doctor, describing him as the "martyr of duty."
Information Minister Manal Abdul Samad for her part mourned Ismail in a tweet,
describing him as “Lebanon’s angel.”“He died after contracting the virus from
one of the patients. He dedicated his time and life to help others in the face
of coronavirus,” she said. “Our white army is working silently. Aid the medical
sector in the war against the virus through abiding by the measures,” the
minister added, stressing that “precaution is necessary” and that “the disease
is not a joke.”Firas Abiad, head of Beirut's Rafik Hariri University Hospital,
the main public hospital treating COVID-19 patients in Lebanon, said: "Today we
mourn Dr. Loay, our young colleague, who fell while doing his duty, treating a
patient with #Covid19." "We have taken an oath and are willing to sacrifice all
for our patients. Yet this does not take away the heartache or make the loss
tolerable," Abiad tweeted. Lebanon had on Sunday reported 84 more coronavirus
cases, raising the overall tally to 2,856. That tally included 40 deaths and
1,515 recoveries. The country has gradually lifted lockdown measures and opened
Beirut airport to commercial flights at the start of July, after a closure of
more than three months.
Over the past two weeks, the daily infection rate has risen, with dozens of new
cases announced each day. In the highest such increase, the government announced
166 new cases on July 12, including 131 sanitation workers.
At the height of summer, some beaches and bars are again thronging with people.
The health minister on Monday warned of a possible return to lockdown over
"people's behavior" and non-compliance with social distancing. The pandemic
arrived with Lebanon already mired in its worst economic crisis in decades and
many fearing the health sector could not cope with a spike in cases. On Sunday,
Abiad wrote on Twitter: "As the cases increase, more will need
hospitalization... Are hospitals ready?"
Abdel Samad: May the soul of Lebanon's angel Dr. Loai
Ismail rest in peace
NNA/July 21, 2020
Minister of Information, Dr. Manal Abdel Samad Najd, on Monday tweeted, "May the
soul of Lebanon's angel, Dr. Loai Ismail, rest in peace, who has met his fate
after contracting the coronavirus from one of the patients. He [Dr. Ismail]
devoted his time and life to help others in the face of the
Coronavirus."Minister Abdel Samad added: "Our white army is working silently.
Help the medical apparatuses in the fight against the coronavirus. Abide by
preventive measures."
The Minister added the following hashtags to her post: #prevention-is-necessary
#disease-is-not-a-joke
Baabda Palace witnesses array of political, diplomatic, and
university meetings
NNA/July 21, 2020
President Michel Aoun received, Foreign Affairs Minister, Nassif Hitti, today at
Baabda Palace, and was briefed on the results of his visit to Rome and the
Vatican, and the talks he held with officials of the Italian Government and in
the Holy See.
Minister Hitti stated that the officials he met renewed support for Lebanon and
their desire to help it, and keep pace with the reforms undertaken by Lebanon,
which the international community relies on. Hitti also pointed out that Italian
officials reaffirmed their support for the international forces operating in the
South, while preserving their roles and tasks. “As for the Vatican, officials
stressed the importance of Lebanon, the diversity it represents and its role in
its surroundings and the world, and the necessity of providing all kinds of
support and keeping pace with Lebanon to get out of the current crisis it is
going through. The Holy See also stressed the desire to support Catholic schools
in Lebanon, according to the initiative announced recently” Minister Hitti said.
The Foreign Affairs Minister concluded that the meeting also tackled the
upcoming visit of French Foreign Minister, Jean-Yves Laudrian, to Beirut and the
topics to be discussed, noting that developments in the region and their
repercussions on Lebanon were also discussed during the meeting.
MP Elias Bou Saab:
President Aoun met the former Minister, MP Elias Bou Saab, and discussed with
him current developments. The suffering that the Lebanese are going through in
this period at various levels, and some social and educational initiatives that
are being implemented were also discussed. Bou Saab said that he felt from
President Aoun that, after examining the various causes of corruption, real
reform is necessary in the country as it begins with a transparent investigation
and auditing of financial accounts, especially those in the Central Bank, and
that the President is determined to proceed with until the end.
National Cedar Medal, Dr. Joseph Jabra:
In addition, the President awarded the President of the Lebanese-American
University, Dr. Joseph Jabra, the National Cedar Medal, (Rank of Officer), in
recognition of his educational and university tenders during his presidency of
the university.
A ceremony was also held at the Presidential Palace, which was attended by Dr.
Jabra, his wife, former Minister Bou Saab, former Minister Salim Jreissati,
General Director of the Presidency of the Republic, Dr. Antoine Choucair, the
new LAU President, Dr. Michel Mouawad, a number of members of the Board of
Trustees, vice-presidents, and the family of Dr. Jabra.
Protocol Director-General, Dr. Nabil Shedid, read the reasons for granting the
medal to Dr. Jabra:
“We gather today at the Presidential Palace, to honor a thinker, and role model,
who has always defended the authority of the word, the values of thought, and
the authority of reason. Today, His Excellency the President of the Republic,
General Michel Aoun, honors Dr. Joseph Jabra, the former President of the
Lebanese American University (LAU), who spared no effort in raising brilliant
generations. This is something that deserves the appreciation of the university
family, in which it was known to be competitive, and insisting on high
excellence.
In this message which Dr. Jabra chose, he looked to the high horizons, and it
was not easy, in a country where there were many difficulties. In spite of this,
our generations, who have descended from this university, that Dr. Jabra
presided over since 2004, have succeeded with excellence.
Thanks to his perseverance in giving, in the name of Lebanon’s knowledge, his
harvest became abundant. He contributed to the establishment of the Faculty of
Medicine at LAU, as well as the engineering colleges there, in addition to many
positions he held, the last of which was the President of the International
Association of American Universities and Colleges.
Honorable Doctor Joseph Jabra,
In appreciation of your bids in the name of Lebanon, His Excellency President
Michel Aoun decided to grant you the National Cedar Medal (Rank of Officer). May
your tender continue to serve the role model”.
Dr. Jabra’s Word:
It is an “Honor” that I may not be worthy of, but it, in the depth of meaning it
carries, “An assignment”, which showed me as obligated to abide by its rules, to
be truly a “Lebanese in the service of Lebanon”.
Your Excellency,
It is the feeling itself that overwhelms me, that feeling that has not abandoned
me since I left the country aboard a boat heading to the United States of
America to pursue my higher education, which is, What motivated me to return, in
fulfillment of my homeland, in which I was endowed with the grace of life,
adding to the chain of blessings of the relationship with man, with the giving
land, and with faith, and most importantly, with loyalty ... All of this
resembled a debt that I always had to strive to pay off.
Compliance came to a decision to take over the Presidency of the Lebanese
American University and carry a banner to move it forward, to be, on the level
of the sophistication that distinguished Lebanon in the region, which made
Lebanon among its followers and from its universities, a destination for
everyone who chose to make the path of his future, and build a successful
tomorrow.
I spent sixteen years on this mission, which cleared my conscience and my
feelings of love for Lebanon, and that I should strive to give this country and
its good people a part of what I have, so I worked through my responsibilities
to make the LAU a messenger for the true Lebanon abroad. A sincere team helped
me in my endeavor, who is present with me here today and believes in Lebanon, as
we see it, so we established branches of the Alumni Association numbering nearly
fifty, which spread to all parts of the world, reflecting a beautiful image of
Lebanese youth, left.
In the minds of Lebanon’s history and present that its people want and dream
about.
We have also strengthened the academic system and fed it with the best
educational capabilities. We expanded colleges, increased their numbers, and put
our academic and medical capabilities, especially the College of Medicine, in
the service of our hospital, and we were not satisfied.
Thanks to the effort of this team, our organization proved its social
commitment, and it was at the forefront of those facing the spread of the Corona
epidemic, through our mobile clinic that toured all parts of our country and
conducted laboratory examinations in thousands for free, as a contribution from
us to bear a portion of the responsibility placed on each of us, so that we can
keep our aura which our ancestors devoted to us.
It is Lebanon, to which you have sought, Your Excellency, despite all the
political and economic difficulties facing the country. However, I am confident
that you, with your will and wisdom, are able to overcome the ordeal, and
overcome its effects.
Trust, Mr. President, that higher education is essential to the journey of
rescue and planning for tomorrow, as it has always been like this, and so it
will continue.
Hence, the importance of your personal care for this sensitive file, to protect
it from all interference and preserve it from parasites, as it is a trust that
we are responsible of, but rather it is “Trust” entrusted to us, and we must
strive to carry it, for by higher education we guarantee our country and our
children a path of progress towards a brighter tomorrow, and we achieve for
Lebanon the development it needs to remain a pillar of a civilization that was
launched by men who worshiped science and humanity.
And the service of higher education will remain.
Many thanks to everyone who sought so that the President of the country grants
me the National Cedar Medal, of the rank of officer. I especially mention His
Excellency Minister Elias Bou Saab, Nada Taraby, Dr. Salim Sfeir, President of
the Association of Banks in Lebanon, Dr. Christian Osei. I also thank all of you
for attending my family and my cousins, members of the Board of Trustees of the
Lebanese American University, my fellow colleagues, Vice-Presidents, Dr. Michel
Mouawad, President-elect of LAU. In conclusion, this medal, crowns my
educational career, and obliges me to continue to serve my country wherever I
go. My sincere thanks and deep appreciation to you, Mr. President, for this
pride, which will be my greatest honor throughout my life”.
Minister Bou Saab:
Then, Minister Bou Saab thanked President Aoun for his initiative and generous
gesture which shows his interest in education and his absolute belief that
homelands are built with proper education. About Dr. Jabra’s distinguished
career, MP Bou Saab stressed that history will bear witness to the fingerprint
that Dr. Jabra left in his accomplishments during his assumption of LAU
Presidency, which became one of the most important Lebanese Universities, and
during this period he was able to transform the difficult days, which the
country is passing through, to victory.
“We believe, as we have learned from your Excellency, that we will not give up
under any circumstances, and we will win over every crisis we face. Lebanon is
coming on better days and will be stronger, and we rely on universities and the
educational sector, to help achieve history” Bou Saab added.
President Aoun:
For his side, the President expressed happiness for Dr. Jabra’s imitation of
this medal in the name of all the Lebanese, in appreciation of his gifts and
sacrifices.
“Because he is a man who deserved a lot and gave his life to serve science.
Without knowledge, no progress can be achieved, neither for individuals nor for
homelands. Therefore, we have realized what distinguishes Dr. Jabra, and stands
behind his professional giving which made him realize his dream, which he will
deliver to future generations. Only he who understands the value of something
knows how to guide it” President Aoun asserted.
After the ceremony, a traditional photo was taken.
A phone call with “La Francophonie” Secretary-General:
On the other hand, President Aoun called the Secretary-General of the
International Organization of “La Francophonie”, Louise Mushikiwabou, and
discussed with her the general situation, thanking her for the support which
Lebanon receives from the organization in the current difficult circumstances.
Ms. Mushikiwabou expressed the organization’s support to Lebanon and its
willingness to provide what is needed to help the country overcome the
difficulties it faces.—Presidency Press Office
Al-Rahi Urges Unity to Reach 'U.N. Resolution' on Lebanon
Neutrality
Naharnet/July 20/2020
Maronite Patriarch Beshara al-Rahi on Monday hoped all Lebanese will show a
“unified stance” on his calls for neutrality. “We hope all Lebanese will show a
unified stance in order to reach a resolution from the Security Council and the
U.N. stipulating that Lebanon has an active neutral system that should be
respected by all countries,” said al-Rahi during a meeting with a Kataeb Party
delegation in Diman. “It would then respect itself and become a state that is
strong through its institutions and army and it would defend itself against any
foreign aggression,” the patriarch added. Stressing that “certainly we and
Israel are in a state of constant animosity,” al-Rahi said “active and positive
neutrality is our responsibility all.”“It is a huge responsibility, especially
that Lebanon was the hospital, hotel, tourism and freedom of Arabs and its
neutrality allowed it to gain these labels, but when we engaged in alliances,
parties and military acts we became fully isolated from Arabs and the West,” the
patriarch added.
Ibrahim from Center House: Hariri is keen on Lebanon, its
stability and prosperity
NNA/July 21, 2020
Former Prime Minister Saad Hariri received this afternoon at the Center House,
the General Director of the General Security, Major General Abbas Ibrahim.
After the meeting, Ibrahim said: “I had the honor today to meet with former
Prime Minister Hariri and I think that there is no reason to say why I visit
him. This visit to him is normal, it is not the first time and will not be the
last. I come constantly to this honorable house and visit Prime Minister Hariri.
There is no reason to be surprised or ask about my presence in this house.”
Question: Today, you are visiting the Center House while there is confusion
around what Prime Minister Hassan Diab said “concerning comments we got from the
Arab brothers" and that some people conveyed these comments. It seemed that
after your tour, you conveyed them to the prime minister, especially since all
communication is cut between him and the Arab countries. Were you the link?
Ibrahim: First, Prime Minister Hariri, whether he is in the government or in the
opposition, is keen on Lebanon, its stability and prosperity, and this is not
strange for the Hariri family and not only for former Prime Minister Saad
Hariri. It is inherited from martyr Prime Minister Rafic Hariri. Furthermore,
the relations between Prime Minister Diab and the Arab countries are not cut,
and there are certainly contacts taking place between them. The prime minister
expressed his surprise at this matter and said that he did not and does not
implicate anyone, and specifically not Prime Minister Hariri. He did not accuse
Prime Minister Hariri, who is the keenest on Lebanon, its stability and
prosperity and we all know that.
Question: Did you reach a result in your tour?
Ibrahim: I previously said that I did not ask for help, but rather asked for the
creation of a common economic space between us and the countries that I visited,
in order to secure trade exchange or a common economic interest between Lebanon
and the countries I visited.
Question: Did you reach any result?
Ibrahim: Hopefully, we will reach a result.
Question: Why did you take this tour now and why you in particular?
Ibrahim: I think that all of Lebanon knows that we are going through a difficult
economic and financial crisis and we had to react. As for why me, you have to
ask the person who asked me to do this.
Question: During your visit to the Saudi Ambassador, it was said that the Saudi
response is that Lebanon should return to the Arab lap, and then other matters
would be discussed. It looked as if Saudi response to your request would lead to
responses from the other Arab countries
Ibrahim: I already said that I accepted the invitation of the Saudi ambassador,
and what happened between me and him remains between us, and I am not used to
meeting anyone and then announce the minutes of the meeting.
Question: It was said that the meeting with the Saudi ambassador was not
encouraging and positive?
Ibrahim: What was said and what happened during the meeting are two different
things.
Question: What did you tell Prime Minister Hariri today?
Ibrahim: I came to visit him as usual.
Judge Orders Preventive Assets Freeze of Central Bank
Governor
Naharnet/July 20/2020
Judge Faisal Makki on Monday ordered the preventive freeze of the real estates
and assets of governor of Central Bank of Lebanon Riad Salameh, in connection
with a request filed by lawyers and activists of The People Want to Reform the
System group.The lawyers were named as Hassan Bazzi, Haitham Ezzo, Jad Tohmeh,
Joseph Wanis, Pierre Gemayel, Francois Kamel and Basel Abbas. From June 11-13,
after the Lebanese pound hit a new low on the black market, protests in Lebanon
rallied against Salameh's failure to halt the depreciation.
Ghajar Says Power Cuts to Ease before Midweek
Naharnet/July 20/2020
Energy Minister Raymond Ghajar said on Monday that power supply is going to
notably improve after weeks of power cuts that saw much of the country plunge
into darkness, adding to the gloom of a deepening economic and financial crisis
in the country. “Various Lebanese regions will see gradual but notable
improvement in power supply before Wednesday, which eventually will lead to less
consumption of fuel,” said Ghajar at a joint press conference with Economy
Minister Raoul Nehme. Ghajar who had blamed the wide power cuts over the past
month on two faulty fuel shipments involving the Algerian state energy firm
Sonatrach, said the government is taking all necessary measures to avoid similar
problems. For his part, Nehme slammed fuel traders saying: “There is a fuel
crisis in the country and instead of following the ministry’s legal mechanism,
traders follow the principle of blackmail.”The cuts, stretching in some cases to
20 hours a day, have led generator providers to shut down their machines for
several hours a day to ration existing fuel. As a result, traffic lights in
Beirut have been turned off and hospitals have struggled to make sure their
surgeries and other work can continue without interruption.
Lebanese people, however, already pay for generators that provide backup power
through the daily outages, and electricity prices cannot be increased before the
state is able to provide round-the-clock electricity.
Security Sources: Lebanese Detained in Cyprus Not Linked to Hizbullah
Naharnet/July 20/2020
Security sources denied on Monday reports claiming that a Lebanese detained on
Sunday in Cyprus over drug dealing charges reportedly belongs to Hizbullah, MTV
station said. The sources spoke to MTV on condition of anonymity, stressing that
the suspect, identified by his first initials as G.D., is not a member of
Hizbullah. Al-Arabiya TV reported on Sunday that authorities in Cyprus have
extradited to the United States a Hizbullah member accused of drug dealing.
Cyprus' supreme court had on May 29 upheld an order to extradite a suspected
Hizbullah member to the U.S. on money laundering charges, according to official
media. A five-judge bench unanimously dismissed an appeal against a decision by
a lower court in September 2019 to extradite the man, identified only by his
surname Diab, the Cyprus News Agency said. The suspect was wanted by authorities
in Florida for alleged money laundering crimes.
Fahmi Launches Awareness Campaign over COVID-19
Naharnet/July 20/2020
In light of an uptick in Lebanon’s COVID-19 cases, Interior Minister Mohammed
Fahmi launched a campaign to raise awareness on preventing the virus spread
noting that police will impose “strict” measures to enforce protection, al-Joumhouria
daily reported on Monday. In remarks to the daily, Fahmi said security forces
will be required to “advise and guide people ignoring restrictions,” warning
them that they could be hit with fines if they do not abide by the protection
measures. The Minister urged media outlets to “raise the level of awareness
about the dangers of evading protection measures against coronavirus.”Fahmi said
although fines on people ignoring restrictions are a burden in light of a
difficult economic and social crisis, “but it is their duty to feel national
responsibility to protect themselves and others.”He said “neither the State nor
the society are capable of bearing the consequences on the medical sector and
Lebanese economy if this virus spirals out of control.” Lebanon recorded 84 new
cases of coronavirus raising the total number to 2856, 1515 recoveries and 40
deaths since February 1 when the first COVID-19 case was detected.
Diab chairs meeting of ministerial committee for the
follow-up of waste file
NNA/July 21, 2020
Prime Minister, Dr. Hassan Diab, chaired in the evening a meeting of the
ministerial committee for the follow-up of the waste file. The meeting was
attended by Ministers of Environment and Administrative Development, Demianos
Kattar, Interior and Municipalities,Mohammad Fahmi, Public Works and Transport,
Michel Najjar, Public Health, Hamad Hassan, Agriculture and Culture, Abbas
Mortada, in addition to Director General of the Lebanese Presidency, Antoine
Choucair, Secretary General of the Presidency of the Council of Ministers, Judge
Mahmoud Makie, head of Reconstruction and Development Council Nabil Al Jisr, and
PM Advisor, Assaad Eid.
The Minister of Environment presented the report prepared by the technical
committee, and PM Diab asked attendees to provide observations before submitting
the report before the Council of Ministers.-- PM Press Office
Diab cables Sisi congratulating him on July 23 revolution commemoration
NNA/July 21, 2020
Prime Minister, Dr. Hassan Diab, cabled Egyptian President Abdel Fattah al-Sissi
and his Egyptian counterpart Dr. Mustafa Madbouli, to congratulate them on the
occasion of the July 23 revolution commemoration, wishing more progress and
prosperity for the Egyptian State and reaffirming the deep brotherly relations
and cooperation between the two countries and peoples. Premier Diab also sent a
cable to King Philip of Belgium and to his Belgian counterpart Sophie Wilmès, to
congratulate them on the occasion of the Belgian National Day, praising profound
and excellent relationships linking both countries and looking forward to
strengthening them in the future.--PM Press Office
Diab meets military charter group delegation, Secretary
General of Lebanese-Syrian Supreme Council
NNA/July 21, 2020
Prime Minister Hassan Diab received today a delegation from the Military charter
group, which included retired officers Mounir Akl, Elias Atamesh, Asad Al-Hashem,
Fares El-Khoury, Ghassan Mahfouz, Adnan Darwish, George Saikaly, Abdo Sagheer,
Hamad Haidar and Samir Jaber, in the presence of PM Advisor, Brigadier General
Talal Doughan. After the meeting, Akl said: "We discussed with the Prime
Minister the economic, financial and living conditions, and we demanded that the
first step towards a solution be holding accountable corrupt officials, thieves
and those who have appropriated state funds. We support the self-made Premier
who works day and night to mend the situation in the country after being left
with a burning fire ball in hand... PM Diab is striving to move the country
forward, but people must point out what is right and what is wrong; the
government is leaving no stone unturned, with the assistance of all parties, but
unfortunately some groups with special agendas are working to get in the way of
the State’s and government’s path. We were engaged in the military movement and
are still the spearhead for defending rights and demands in order to secure a
decent living for the citizens and for hungry people, for incomes no longer meet
all the needs. But this does not happen by attacking public and private
property, blocking roads, burning tires, breaking banks, and restricting
liberty. We ask the people who are interested in the advancement of the country
to act in a peaceful way, point out what is right and criticize what is wrong.
Is this government that has been in place for four and a half months only
responsible for the hunger that has struck the people? It is responsible for
corruption, theft and looting of public funds? Of course not, since the
government is responsible for disclosing the names of thieves and corrupt
people, and putting them on trial. This is our demand”. Later on, PM Diab met
with the Secretary General of the Lebanese-Syrian Supreme Council, Nasri Khoury,
in the presence of PM Advisor, Khodor Taleb, with talks touching on the
conditions of the displaced Syrians.—PM Press Office
Hariri receives Tarraf
NNA/July 21, 2020
Former Prime Minister Saad Hariri received this afternoon at the Center House
the Ambassador of the European Union to Lebanon Ralph Tarraf, who said that “the
meeting focused on local and regional developments and the constructive role
played by Prime Minister Hariri in the various issues raised.”--Hariri Press
Office
Transfer of authority of Spanish brigade
NNA/July 21, 2020
The Transfer of Authority Ceremony for UNIFIL Spanish Brigade BRILIB XXXII on
successful completion of a tenure of Eight months was organized in HQ UNP 7-2 in
Marjayoun. The Chief Guest of the ceremony was UNIFIL Force Commander Major
General Stefano del Col. Due to ongoing COVID-19 Pandemic, the ceremony was
conducted at much smaller scale than usual, with very limited number of
attendances.The Spanish Brigade 'The Legion - Rey Alfonso XIII'' came to Lebanon
from the southern part of Spain, Almeria. This is the Fourth time that this
battalion has taken part in the United Nation Peace keeping Mission with 600
troops, presently this brigade is being commanded by Brigadier General Marcos
Llago Navarro. During last six months, the brigade has achieved immense
popularity for its support to the local public. The brigade assisted the local
population by various projects funded by both UNIFIL and the Spanish government.
These investments were made in the fields of healthcare, municipal development,
education and building up of infrastructure for the local villages. Special
emphasis was made to improve the education infrastructure as the Commander
believes that the children will be the future of Lebanon and all efforts were
made so that they get an encouraging environment for honing their skills and
shaping the future. In this regard in the past six months, the brigade has also
taken an endeavour to teach Spanish to local population.
In terms of operations during its tenure of service, the brigade has
successfully implemented the Security Council resolution 1701 in its AOR in
coordination with all multinational battalions of UNIFIL SECTOR EAST and LAF.
The troops under this brigade has kept a continuous watch to ensure peace and
stability in the region. One of the most important achievements, which needs
special mention, is the increased cooperation between UNIFIL units and LAF units
of 7th Brigade and 5th regiment which has been achieved by a series of joint
trainings and joint patrols.
During his speech, the Force Commander of UNIFIL highly appreciated the great
professionalism and efforts of outgoing brigade in ensuring peace and stability
in south of Lebanon. He also congratulated them for their successful tenure and
gave best wishes to the brigade for their future endeavours.
The incoming brigade BRILIB XXXIII 'The Airborne Infantry Regiment- N?poles 4'
is being commanded by Brigadier General Luis Jes?s Fern?ndez Herrero. The
brigade is joining the UNIFIL for the fourth time. Brigadier General Luis Jes?s
Fernandez Herrero, himself, has served twice, in 2007 and 2010, in UNIFIL before
this mission. All the preventive measures related to COVID-19 virus spread were
followed during the ceremony.
Bukhari receives phone call from Berri checking on Saudi Monarch's health
NNA/July 21, 2020
Saudi Ambassador to Lebanon, Walid bin Abdullah Bukhari, on Monday received a
phone call from House Speaker, Nabih Berri, to check on the health of the
Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques King Salman bin Abdulaziz, as per a statement
by the Saudi Embassy, following the announcement of the Royal Court that the
Saudi Monarch has been admitted to the King Faisal Specialist Hospital for
medical examinations for gall bladder inflammation. Speaker Berri wished the
Saudi Monarch speedy recovery, statement added. In turn, Ambassador Bukhari
highly appreciated and thanked Speaker Berri for his sincere brotherly
sentiments, stressing that the Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques King is in good
health.
Minister of Information broaches role of media with World Bank advisor, Modern
University delegation
NNA/July 21, 2020
Minister of Information, Dr. Manal Abdel Samad Najd, on Monday welcomed at her
ministerial office World Bank advisor, Dr. Mounir Hamza, with whom she discussed
the latest developments, as well as the important role of media and the
modernization of public administrations. Minister Abdel Samad separately met
with a delegation from the “Modern University for Management and Science”,
headed by President of the University’s Board of Trustees, Dr. Hatem Alameh.
Following the meeting, Dr. Alameh indicated that the meeting had been an
occasion to brief Minister Abdul Samad on the University’s activities,
especially amid the current difficult circumstances. "Universities are currently
going through a very difficult situation,” he said. “We are joining forces with
the benevolent figures in this country to seek the best means out of the
crisis,” he added. Alameh then stressed the importance of joining forces between
the media and education sectors to get students ready for today’s challenges,
especially in light of the current collapse and its devastating effect on the
high rate of unemployment.
ICMP welcomes appointment of members of Lebanon National
Commission for the Missing and Forcibly Disappeared
NNA/July 21, 2020
The International Commission on Missing Persons (ICMP) has welcomed in a
statement on Monday the appointment of the members of the Lebanon National
Commission for the Missing and Forcibly Disappeared, who have been sworn in
before the President of the Republic, General Michel Aoun.
“These appointments underline recognition of the importance of resolving the
issue of missing persons as an opportunity to assert state responsibility, and
thus enhance confidence in public institutions on this issue,” said ICMP
Director-General Kathryne Bomberger. “As the only international organization
working exclusively on the issue of missing persons, ICMP stands ready to
support Lebanon’s efforts to address this issue in an effective and impartial
way, and to help families of the missing to secure truth and justice.”For years,
family associations and civil society have worked to keep the missing persons
issue in public view, and together with NGOs they have called on the authorities
to launch a sustained and comprehensive process to account for the missing. In
2019, Lebanon passed Law 105 for the Missing and Forcibly Disappeared Persons,
and the appointment of the members of the Commission marks the next important
step in addressing the issue. ICMP is a treaty-based intergovernmental
organization with Headquarters in The Hague, the Netherlands. Its mandate is to
secure the cooperation of governments and others in locating missing persons
from conflict, human rights abuses, disasters, organized crime, irregular
migration and other causes and to assist them in doing so. It is the only
international organization tasked exclusively to work on the issue of missing
persons. It has helped governments to develop legislation to enable families of
the missing to assert their rights; and has assisted governments in the
excavation of more than 3,000 mass graves using advanced forensic techniques,
and in the scientific identification of tens of thousands of missing persons
from around the world, using cutting-edge DNA methods.—ICMP
AUB President Dr. Fadlo Khuri addressees AUB Community
NNA/July 21, 2020
In a message sent to the AUB community this morning, President Fadlo R. Khuri
considered that “this past week was an exceptionally difficult one as we were
forced to lose 850 members of our community, with 650 staff laid off and 200
more whose contracts will not be renewed or who will retire and not be replaced.
Over the past months, we have worked diligently to identify where job reduction
could be realized without jeopardizing operations and allowing AUB to remain
affordable, all while continuing to provide transformative education and
world-class patient care. These efforts, led by the administration and in
collaboration with the Workers and Staff Syndicate of AUB, substantially reduced
the number of jobs lost from those previously predicted to 850. At the same
time, we rapidly built an expanded social safety net, whereby we are paying
between 6-24 months of severance pay based on a sliding scale of years of
service, continuing to pay for the AUB education of the departing employees’
children in undergraduate programs until their graduation, maintaining all
funding of school education for one year, and offering much-needed health
benefits.”
“Due to several factors, most layoffs came from our medical center and they came
from all ranks, including the prior senior management team. AUBMC did not
maximize accrual of adequate reserves over the past decade and mobilized slowly
to sufficiently control costs once the Lebanese financial crisis began to
accelerate in 2019. The medical center was being developed to provide Lebanon
and the peoples of the region with world-class patient care on an expanded,
state-of-the-art level, a mission we will cautiously resume once Lebanon and the
region’s economies stabilize. In this vastly diminished economy, AUBMC has a
substantial over-staffing problem in many units, which is unsustainable and had
to be urgently addressed. AUBMC Director Joe Otayek and Interim Dean of the
Faculty of Medicine (FM) Dr. Ghazi Zaatari, along with an entirely new,
homegrown leadership team, are committed to a more sustainable, strategic, and
compassionate approach to both the medical center and our historic
medical school. We are confident they will set AUBMC and FM on the right path”,
he added. Khuri said that “we fully understand the dire impact of the layoffs
given the disastrous state of Lebanon’s economy, but it was precisely those
circumstances that made it impossible for AUB to avoid this severe measure.
Before reaching this point, every avenue was explored to cut costs and increase
efficiency on campus and at the medical center, including closure of
underperforming university units. Additional funding support was sought from the
US and Lebanese governments and from private foundations and individuals. Those
in top leadership positions and some higher-paid faculty and staff members have
been giving back 10-20% of their salary for months. I myself have been giving
back 25% of my salary since mid-November 2019. Capital construction projects
have been canceled or delayed, non-critical maintenance deferred, university
travel eliminated, and hiring frozen.”
“It is always important to acknowledge where we could have done better. The
reality is that letting this many people go from the AUB family was never going
to be easy. Leaving one’s home and family because of external economic factors
is even more painful. The manner of the departures, especially at AUBMC, could
and should have been better handled, and some confusion and pain could have been
avoided. Many have questioned the presence of the army and police at AUBMC. To
be clear, the security presence was made necessary after credible external
threats were received earlier in the week, which led to recommendations for
high-level security. The safety of the personnel, the patients, the students,
and the general public was and will always be of paramount priority. We
therefore reluctantly abided by these recommendations. We recognize that this
security presence should have been better managed. We will learn from this
experience but as we always do, these are things we own and will build on”, he
continued.
“In these heartbreaking times, we must all set aside our differences and work
together to strive towards a better tomorrow. Our greatest concerns at this time
include carefully restoring morale, especially at AUBMC, empowering our precious
human assets while we continue to educate the best and brightest, serve our
community, carry out groundbreaking research, and provide world-class care at
our medical center. We must do this all while balancing the budget, with a
disproportionate amount of our revenues now being generated in a collapsing
Lebanese economy, amidst the COVID-19 pandemic and deep global recession.”Khuri
concluded: “As I have stated repeatedly over the past five years, we must strive
to first help ourselves in order for others to believe we are worth helping.
That is true for AUB, for the higher education and healthcare sectors in Lebanon
and the Arab world, and more than likely for the peoples of the region. AUB has
always been a vital institution for Lebanon, the region, and beyond. Its
community has repeatedly come together in the face of monumental challenges. We
now must again rely on the strength of our community to emerge from this
unprecedented series of crises. We need our outstanding AUB Board, faculty,
staff, students, alumni community, and friends to stand by us, continue to give
generously whenever they can, feel free to criticize thoughtfully, but also to
truly partner with us in building a better, more sustainable, and more inclusive
AUB.”—AUB
Bassil muddles Lebanese debate on neutrality, provokes
Palestinian pushback
The Arab Weekly/July 20/2020
BEIRUT – Palestinian factions condemned on Sunday statements by the president of
Lebanon’s Free Patriotic Movement (PMF) Gebran Bassil that Palestinian refugees
hinder his country’s efforts to preserve “neutrality.”In a statement, the
Alliance of Palestinian Forces in Lebanon, which includes most Palestinian
factions, called to confront “all the malicious media campaigns that smack of
racism, hatred and hatred.” The Palestinian factions also rejected their being
put on the same footing as Israel.
After meeting with Maronite Patriarch Mar Bechara Boutros al-Rai in the northern
village of Al-Diman on Sunday, Bassil said that “neutrality can succeed if
neighbouring countries recognise the principle and apply it by removing
unpredictable foreign elements at home.”Bassil said Palestinians in Lebanon are
among “unpredictable” foreign elements, without elaborating further. “We are
with neutrality that will help Lebanon maintain its unity and defend it from
attacks by Israel,” Bassil said.
“Neutrality is required from us and others, and is a form of strategic
positioning,” he added. The PMF’s leader also said that both internal and
external conditions should be in place and that there should be national
commitment to neutrality. During mass sermon in Diman earlier in the day, Rai
reiterated his call for Lebanon to adopt a neutral stance, which he said is not
a sectarian, factional or foreign proposal “but rather a recovery of our
identity and basic nature, and a path of salvation for all Lebanese with no
exception.” The patriarch said the system of neutrality requires the presence of
a strong state with a strong army, institutions and judiciary capable of
defending itself, preserving the unity of its people and creating political
stability and economic growth. “My hope is that a real simple understanding of
the concept of an active system of neutrality will be achieved through
scientific intellectual dialogues that reveal its legal, national and political
meaning, and its importance for stability and prosperity,” he said. The Shia
camp, particularly the Iran-backed Hezbollah group and the Amal movement, have
yet to comment on Rai’s call for neutrality. The Higher Islamic Shia Council
chief Sheikh Abdul Amir Qabalan, however, hit back on Sunday. He said neutrality
does not differentiate between the West and the East, accusing some parties of
sympathising with “traitors and collaborators” under various pretexts in order
to tarnish the image of the “resistant Lebanon that triumphed over the Zionist
enemy.”He also warned against losing sight of national and ethical interests and
the means of rescuing Lebanon from regional and international tensions that seek
to tear it apart.
Qatar's Hezbollah funding exposed by whistle-blower
contractor
Damien McElroy/The National/July 20/2020
Consultant claims he was involved in months of negotiations with Qatar over
hundreds of thousands of euros to suppress devastating dossier
A whistle-blower has claimed that he earned tens of thousands of euros from
Qatar for hiding a dossier that documented the country's support for Hezbollah.
German press have reported that the security consultant was offered a total
payment of €750,000 (Dh3.1 million) to suppress the information he had gathered
about Qatar's illicit support for terrorism. The man, identified only as Jason,
said he spent several months in negotiations in 2019 with a Qatari emissary in
Europe.
A German business executive who was reported to have witnessed some of the
meetings said information had been passed to the Qataris that provided
"transparency" in the "fight against certain critical, anti-Israeli networks".
Six meetings took place between the consultant and the Qataris before the talks
broke down. Jason reportedly believed that he could receive a payment of €10m
from Qatar to buy the evidence he had compiled. He said the information offered
Qatar an opportunity to purge "shady people in their own ranks", including a
top-ranked general in Doha.
In a familiar pattern tracked to Qatar's funding for the Muslim Brotherhood, the
money to Hezbollah was funnelled through the country's charity sector. Outfits
like Qatar Charity have bankrolled a variety of groups politically active
throughout Europe.
As a political and military entity, Hezbollah has been proscribed around Europe
with Germany and Britain becoming the latest countries to add the group to their
banned list. Under an outline deal considered by both the consultant and the
Qatari representative, the man would have taken monthly payments to maintain a
line of communication with the Qatari general, by whom he was also being paid,
to build up more information on his activities.
Jason also reportedly had first-hand information on arms deals by Qatar with
Eastern European armament factories that would have caused the country further
embarrassment. "[Jason] came across some embarrassing information while based in
Doha," he said. "There was an alleged arms deal with war material from Eastern
Europe that was supposed to be handled by a company in Qatar. And there were
alleged money flows from several rich Qataris to exiled Lebanese people that
involved money flows from Doha to Hezbollah." In the first half of 2019 the leak
of the dossier in the German press would have been highly embarrassing for Qatar
as it pressed forward with its construction programme for hosting the 2022 World
Cup. With Hezbollah on official terror lists in the US and Europe, the country's
diplomatic standing would have been compromised, according to Jason's account of
his conversations with the Qatari envoys.
Qatar spends tens of millions of euros in Europe to support institutes and
organisations that have drawn concerns over the risk of radicalisation. Doha
maintains friendly ties with Hezbollah's patron Iran, which in turn has suffered
a blow after European security agencies exposed Tehran's intelligence network
run by its embassies in Germany, Belgium and France.
The Latest English LCCC Miscellaneous
Reports And News published on July 20-21/2020
Syria Reports Israeli Air Raids on Capital
Associated Press/Naharnet/July 20/2020
The Syrian military said the country's air defenses responded on Monday to
Israeli air raids in south Damascus that caused only material damage, and
residents said loud explosions rocked the capital. It was not clear what the
targets were. The air raids, which came just before 10 p.m. (1900 GMT),
continued for more than 15 minutes. Residents reported hearing at least four
explosions in the capital. A military official quoted in Syrian state media said
the attack was carried out by Israeli jets that took off from the Golan Heights,
which Israel seized from Syria in the 1967 war. The unnamed official said air
defenses responded and downed most of the missiles. He said the attack caused
material damage only. The Britain-based Syrian Observatory for Human Rights,
which monitors the country's civil war, said the suspected Israeli strikes
targeted government and Iranian militia posts. Israel rarely comments on such
reports, but is believed to have carried out scores of raids targeting Iran's
military presence in Syria. In the past two months alone, Syria has accused
Israel of carrying out at least eight air raids on its territory. The last
reported strikes came in late June. Iran is a key ally of the Syrian government
in the nearly decade-long civil war. Israel views Iran as a regional menace and
has vowed to prevent any permanent Iranian military buildup in Syria,
particularly near the frontier. In recent months, Israeli officials have also
expressed concern that Hizbullah, an Iran-backed Lebanese group that operates in
Syria, is trying to establish facilities to produce precision-guided missiles.
Tensions have also risen along the Israel-Lebanon border. The strikes Monday
came a day after Syrians voted in government-held areas to elect a new
parliament. The vote is the third to take place in Syria since the civil war
began in March 2011. It has killed more than 400,000, displaced half the
country's population and caused more than five million to become refugees,
mostly in neighboring countries.
Iran executes man convicted of spying for CIA, Mossad
AFP/July 20, 2020
Tehran (AFP) - Iran on Monday executed a former translator convicted of spying
for the US and Israel, including helping to locate a top Iranian general killed
later by the Americans, the judiciary said. The killing of Major General Qasem
Soleimani in a US drone strike near Baghdad airport in January brought
decades-old arch enemies Iran and the United States to the brink of conflict.
The judiciary's Mizan Online website said Mahmoud Mousavi Majd's death "sentence
was carried out on Monday morning over the charge of espionage so that the case
of his betrayal to his country will be closed forever". Its spokesman said
earlier this month that Majd had been sentenced to death for spying on "various
security fields, especially the armed forces and the Quds Force and the
whereabouts and movements of martyr General Qasem Soleimani". Majd had been
found guilty of receiving large sums of money from both the US Central
Intelligence Agency and Israel's Mossad, said the spokesman Gholamhossein
Esmaili. Soleimani headed the Quds Force, the foreign operations arm of Iran's
Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps. Iran retaliated against the United States for
his death by firing a volley of ballistic missiles at US troops stationed in
Iraq, but US President Donald Trump opted against responding militarily. While
the attack on the western Iraqi base of Ain Al-Asad left no US soldiers dead,
dozens suffered brain trauma.
'American dollars'
Majd was arrested about two years ago and was not directly involved in the
killing of Soleimani, according to a statement the judiciary issued in June.
Majd had migrated to Syria in the 1970s with his family and worked as an English
and Arabic language translator at a company, Mizan said. When war broke out, he
chose to stay in the country while his family left. "His knowledge of Arabic and
familiarity with Syria's geography made him close to Iranian military advisers
and he took responsibilities in groups stationed from Idlib to Latakia," the
site added.
Iran increasingly obsessed with China deal, blames Israel
for controversy
Jerusalem Post/July 20/2020
Iran accuses the US State Department, members of the former Pahlavi monarchy and
Israel of being against the China deal.
Iran is obsessed with getting a deal with China at any cost. It is so obsessed,
it has directed its media to begin to blame Israel and “the Zionists” for any
controversy at the heart of its discussions with China.
The reality is that Iran’s own populists, led by former president Mahmoud
Ahmadinejad, had raised alarms about the Iranian regime selling out to Beijing.
Then Iran’s propaganda machine turned its ire on the “monarchists,” blaming
dissidents abroad for the problem. Now it zooms in on its usual scapegoat:
Israel.
How do we know this? Iran’s media had several front-page stories on Sunday
slamming Israel, including this newspaper, for making its China deal
controversial. What is the controversy? Iran is trying to come to a multi-decade
agreement with China.
Critics allege Iran will give China major concessions and deals in an effort to
get around US sanctions. Meanwhile, Iran’s allies, such as Hezbollah, are also
focused on a deal with China for Lebanon.
The first article at Tasnim News Agency over the weekend says Iran is shifting
to a Beijing strategy because China also wants to pressure the US: “China’s
growing cooperation with Iran in various fields is a symbol of change in
Beijing’s strategy against Washington.” The world has completely changed, Iran
says, and many countries no longer listen to US demands or unilateral policies,
and “countries are willing to confront the US.
Next, Tasnim quotes Majid Reza Harari, head of the Iran-China Chamber of
Commerce, to discuss the agreement. The article is titled: “The role of the
Zionist regime in the media controversy against the 25-year agreement [with
China].” The article notes that Iran-China discussions about a longer agreement
date back to 1997. In addition, the issue of a 25-year deal is merely symbolic.
The countries may have other addenda to their deal, such as a free-trade zone or
work at the Port of Jask, the report says.
Iran accuses the US State Department, members of the former Pahlavi monarchy and
Israel of being against the China deal. “My analysis is that the reasons for
these rumors is that it relates to Israel’s long-term economic interest in the
Middle East,” Harari says. Israel’s partnership with China has been jeopardized,
he says, adding: “We certainly see such an alliance against this agreement in
the world.”
Iran’s road map in this respect looks back to history and argues China never
attempted to colonize Iran, unlike the UK or other countries. Harari argues that
China’s treatment of Iran is, therefore, a better track record than the US or
UK. He also notes that the current government in Tehran is oriented toward the
West and would prefer a deal with France if they could get it. He says it would
be welcome if China would build thousands of kilometers of high-speed trains in
Iran and if China and Iran could work on 5G and other technologies.
It is clear from the report that Iran is moving cautiously and thinking about
many angles of the potential Iran-China deal. However, the Iranian regime is
seeking to pin some of the blame on Israel now, in addition to the US, Saudi
Arabia, “monarchists” and also local populists.
Statement from International Coordination and Response
Group for the victims of Flight PS752 on Iran delivering flight recorders
July 20, 2020 - Ottawa, Ontario - Global Affairs Canada
Canada, Ukraine, Sweden, Afghanistan and the United Kingdom, members of the
International Coordination and Response Group for the victims of Flight PS752,
today issued the following statement:
“While we welcome the delivery of Flight PS752’s recorders to France’s Civil
Aviation Safety Investigation and Analysis Bureau, this is long overdue, and is
only a step towards completing the safety investigation.
“We reiterate our demand for Iran to conduct a full, transparent, and
independent flight safety investigation in accordance with international
standards.
“The Coordination Group will continue working to ensure transparency,
accountability and justice, including reparations, for the families of the
victims of this terrible tragedy.”
Tehran pressures Kadhimi with accusations of involvement in Soleimani’s
assassination
The Arab Weekly/July 20/2020
BAGHDAD - Iran has suggested it has evidence of the involvement of the Iraqi
intelligence service, when it was headed by current Prime Minister Mustafa al-Kadhimi,
in the US raid early this year near Baghdad airport that killed its infamous
general, Qassem Soleimani.
The new claim came ahead of Kadhimi’s scheduled (and temporarily postponed)
visit to Saudi Arabia as part of his first foreign tour, which is also to
include Iran, the United States and other countries. The accusations coincided
with Iranian Foreign Minister Mohammad Javad Zarif’s visit to Baghdad.
The Kata’ib Hezbollah militia in Iraq had previously directly accused Kadhimi of
personal involvement in the raid that had killed Soleimani and his aide, Abu
Mahdi al-Muhandis, who was the de facto field commander of the Popular
Mobilisation Forces (PMF) in Iraq. Tehran, however, has not formally endorsed
this accusation. Iraq watchers know well that the Kata’ib Hezbollah militia is
an Iraqi proxy of Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), and that its
positions express the positions of Iranian hard-liners.
Following the unofficial announcement at the beginning of this month of
Kadhimi’s intention to visit Saudi Arabia, Iran and the United States, Iraqi
media controlled by the IRGC began circulating a list of five officers of the
Iraqi intelligence service they said were involved in planning Soleimani’s
assassination.
Iran is perceived as the master puppeteer of a wide spectrum of Iraqi media that
it controls through the so-called Islamic Radio and Television Union affiliated
with the IRGC, which is also active in Yemen, Syria and Lebanon.
This Iranian media escalation reached a feverish peak on the eve of Zarif’s
official visit to Baghdad Sunday. Iranian diplomats announced that Tehran has
“compelling evidence that two Iraqi officials, along with a number of
employees,” were involved in planning Soleimani’s assassination.
Observers believe that the goal of Iran’s escalation is to intimidate Kadhimi
before he embarks on his visits to Saudi Arabia and the United States. For
Tehran, the Iraqi prime minister appears serious about strengthening his
government’s relations with Riyadh and Washington, both of which Tehran consider
enemies.
Iranian diplomats have suggested that Tehran will bring up the issue of
Soleimani’s assassination and of those involved in it during Kadhimi’s visit to
the Iranian capital in the next few days. A diplomatic source said that
Soleimani’s assassination is one of the items on the agenda of security talks
between Tehran and Baghdad during Kadhimi’s visit. Judging by the latest
Tehran-instigated media campaign in Iraq against the Kadhimi government,
observers believe that Iran will not hesitate to blackmail Kadhimi if it senses
any resistance or insurrection on his part.
With previous Iraqi heads of government, Tehran has always used the carrot and
stick approach. But, this time, experts believe, it may have to resort to new
language if it wants to maintain good relations with Kadhimi, who seems to have
already picked other options than blind obedience to Tehran.
Iraqi political sources say that Iran cannot accept the reality of widespread
Iraqi popular rejection of the policies of all its allies in Baghdad, which was
clearly expressed in the October 2019 uprising in which hundreds of thousands of
Iraqi Shias chanted slogans against Iranian Supreme Leader Ayatollay Ali
Khamenei and demanded an end to Iran’s negative influence in their country.
The sources pointed out that the card of the October uprising may be used by
Kadhimi as an effective weapon in his dealings with Iran, provided he fortifies
his internal flanks by ensuring the military establishment’s loyalty to the
state.
Observers believe that Iran is aware of the depth of its crisis in Iraq after
the Iraqi Shia street during the October uprising shattered the myth that Tehran
is the protector of the Shia sect. Iraqi observers distinguish between two types
of Iranian response to the significant change in Iraqi Shias’ mood — a change
caused by the behaviour of the parties and militias loyal to Iran. On the one
hand, there is the response of the Iranian state, represented by President
Hassan Rohani and Zarif. On the other, there is the response of Iran of the
Islamic Revolution, represented by Khamenei and the IRGC.
The Iranian state wants to maintain Tehran’s hegemony in Iraq through soft
power, using diplomatic tools, economic penetration and quiet influence in
politics, but revolutionary Iran insists on using noise and chaos to maintain
its grip on Iraq, as it looks at it through the eyes of Iraqi militia leaders
who see themselves as above the law and say thatKadhimi is just America’s agent
who wants to revitalise relations with Saudi Arabia.
Many Iraqis do not hear about the state-based Iran because of all the din made
by revolutionary Iran through its proxy media in Iraq against the United States,
Saudi Arabia and Kadhimi and his government. For his part, Kadhimi needs a
magical formula to manage Tehran’s complex influence in Iraq, according to
observers who believe that the Iraqi prime minister should be patient in order
to avoid falling into the trap of an early confrontation that Iran wants to draw
him into with the goal of bringing down his government.
Zarif arrived in Baghdad very early Sunday morning, even before Iraqi official
circles were up and about, on a visit whose timing is causing controversy. It
came about 48 hours before Kadhimi’s scheduled visit to Saudi Arabia, which was
postponed after the Saudi monarch was hospitalised.
Despite what appeared to be a busy schedule for Zarif in Baghdad, including
meetings with the heads of government, the republic and the parliament, as well
as with a spectrum of political leaders, including Ammar al-Hakim, leader of al-Hikma
Movement, and Hadi al-Amiri, leader of the Badr Organisation, Zarif’s statements
were brief. Political discussions between Iraq and Iran taking place through
official delegations are usually kept strictly confidential.
Kadhimi reiterated his country’s steadfast stance in seeking to assert its
balanced and positive role in making peace in the region. “Iraq seeks to assert
its balanced and positive role in making peace and progress in the region, which
will bring all of its people more stability, prosperity and sustainable
development,” he said as he received Zarif. In turn, Zarif affirmed that “Iran
is highly interested in the upcoming visit of the Iraqi Prime Minister to Iran,
to start a new phase of cooperation between the two countries.”Iraqi Foreign
Minister Fuad Hussein stressed in the press conference he held with his Iranian
counterpart that Iraq is working to safeguard Iraq from international tensions
and seeks to protect Iraqi sovereignty. “A strong Iraq means a strong region,
and we seek balanced relations with all of our neighbours according to Iraq’s
national interest and the principle of non-interference in internal affairs,” he
added.
UAE's Amal Spacecraft Rockets toward Mars in Arab World 1st
Associated Press/Naharnet/July 20/2020
A United Arab Emirates spacecraft rocketed into blue skies from a Japanese
launch center Monday at the start of a seven-month journey to Mars on the Arab
world's first interplanetary mission. The liftoff of the Mars orbiter named Amal,
or Hope, starts a rush to fly to Earth's neighbor that is scheduled to be
followed in the next few days by China and the United States.At the space center
in Dubai, people watching were transfixed by the liftoff, then cheered and
clapped, with one woman with offering a celebratory cry common for weddings.
Amal blasted off from the Tanegashima Space Center aboard a Mitsubishi Heavy
Industries' H-IIA rocket on time at 6:58 a.m. (2158 GMT Sunday) after being
delayed five days by bad weather.
Mitsubishi later said the probe successfully separated from the rocket and was
now on its solo journey to Mars. The probe was sending signals that would be
analyzed later but everything appeared good for now, Omran Sharaf, the UAE Mars
mission director told journalists in Dubai about an hour and a half after
liftoff. Amal is set to reach Mars in February 2021, the year the UAE celebrates
50 years since the country's formation. In September that year, Amal will start
transmitting Martian atmospheric data, which will be made available to the
international scientific community, Sharaf said. "The UAE is now a member of the
club and we will learn more and we will engage more and we'll continue
developing our space exploration program," UAE Space Agency chief Mohammed Al
Ahbabi told a joint online news conference from Tanegashima.
At Mohammed bin Rashid Space Center in Dubai, Emirati men in their traditional
white kandora robes and women in their black abayas watched the liftoff. As its
stages separated, a cheer went out from men seated on the floor. They began
clapping, one using his face mask, worn due to the coronavirus pandemic, to wipe
away a tear.
"It was great to see everything going according to schedule today. It looks like
things are all on track. It's a huge step in terms of space exploration to have
a nation like the UAE taking that giant leap to send a spacecraft to Mars," said
Fred Watson, Australia's astronomer-at-large. "Being on route to a planet like
Mars is an exceptional achievement." A newcomer in space development, the UAE
has successfully put three Earth observation satellites into orbit. Two were
developed by South Korea and launched by Russia, and a third — its own — was
launched by Japan.
A successful mission to Mars would be a major step for the oil-dependent economy
seeking a future in space, coming less than a year after the launch of the first
UAE astronaut, Hazzaa Ali Almansoori. He spent over a week at the International
Space Station last fall. The UAE has set a goal to build a human colony on Mars
by 2117.
"It sends a very strong message to the Arab youth that if the UAE is able to
reach Mars in less than 50 years, they could do much more," Sharaf told The
Associated Press on Sunday as his colleagues prepared for the launch.
The Emiratis also acknowledged it represented a step forward for the Arab world,
the home of mathematicians and scientists for centuries before the wars and
chaos that have gripped wide swathes of it in recent times. "So the region has
been going through tough times in the past decades, if not centuries," Sharaf
said. "Now we have the case of the UAE, a country that's moving forward with its
plans, looking at the future and the future of region also."
For its first Mars mission, the UAE chose partners instead of doing it all on
its own. "Developing a spacecraft is not easy even if there is ample funding,"
said Junya Terazono, an astronomer at Aizu University. Emirati scientists worked
with researchers at the University of Colorado Boulder, University of
California, Berkeley, and Arizona State University. The spacecraft was assembled
at Boulder and transported to Japan as the two countries looked to expand their
ties with the rich and politically stable Middle Eastern nation. The Amal
spacecraft, along with its launch, cost $200 million, according to Sharaf.
Operation costs at Mars have yet to be divulged. Amal, about the size of a small
car, carries three instruments to study the upper atmosphere and monitor climate
change while circling the red planet for at least two years. It is set to follow
up on NASA's Maven orbiter sent to Mars in 2014 to study how the planet went
from a warm, wet world that may have harbored microbial life during its first
billion years, to the cold, barren place of today. Hope also plans to send back
images of weather changes.
Japan has long collaborated with the U.S. and other partners in defense and
space technology, and the resource-poor country has traditionally kept friendly
ties with Middle Eastern countries. Japan's launch services are known for
accuracy and an on-time record, but the providers are working to cut costs to be
more internationally competitive. Two other Mars missions are planned in coming
days. China aims to explore the Martian surface with an orbiter and rover and to
search for water and ice with a launch expected around Thursday. The U.S. plans
to send a rover named Perseverance to search for signs of ancient life and
collect rock and soil samples for return to Earth. Liftoff is targeted for July
30. Japan has its own Mars mission planned in 2024. It plans to send spacecraft
to the Martian moon Phobos to collect samples to bring back to Earth in 2029.
Turkey Urges 'Immediate' End to Haftar Support in Libya
Agence France Presse/Naharnet/July 20/2020
Turkey on Monday urged an "immediate" end to the support for rebel commander
Khalifa Haftar in Libya after trilateral talks held in Ankara between Libyan,
Maltese and Turkish officials. Turkey earlier this year stepped up its support
for the Tripoli-based Government of National Accord (GNA) after Haftar launched
an offensive in April 2019 to seize the capital. Libya has been entrenched in
chaos since the 2011 overthrow of longtime dictator Moammar Gadhafi with rival
political and armed groups battling for control. Haftar is backed by Egypt and
the United Arab Emirates -- countries with whom Turkey's relations are strained
-- as well as Russia. "It is essential that all kind of help and support given
to putschist Haftar, which prohibits ensuring Libya's peace, tranquility,
security and territorial integrity, ends immediately," Turkish Defense Minister
Hulusi Akar said. His comments came after a meeting with the interior ministers
of Libya and Malta at the defense ministry in the Turkish capital. Haftar's
backers should "stop supporting an unrealistic and wrong project," GNA Interior
Minister Fathi Bashaga said, according to a Turkish defense ministry
translation. "The international community should prioritize the preservation of
a united Libya," Malta's Interior Minister Byron Camilleri said, joined by Akar
and Bashaga. After the GNA signed security and maritime agreements with Turkey
last year, Ankara's military support including drones helped it re-impose
control over Libya's northwest.
Arbil Denies Handing Syria Kurd Official's Niece to Turkey
Agence France Presse/Naharnet/July 20/2020
Iraqi Kurdish authorities on Monday denied handing over to Turkey the niece of
an influential Syrian Kurdish official wanted by Ankara, as claimed by her
family. The interior ministry in northern Iraq's semi-autonomous Kurdish region
dismissed the accusation from the family of Dalia Mahmoud Muslim, echoing an
account given by official Turkish news agency Anadolu. Citing security sources,
Anadolu reported Saturday that the 21-year-old had "handed herself in" to
Turkish security forces on July 15 in a southern province of Turkey. Dalia
Mahmoud Muslim is the niece of Saleh Muslim, longtime co-chair of the Democratic
Union Party (PYD), political arm of the main Syrian Kurdish militia, the
People's Protection Units (YPG). The YPG is viewed as a "terrorist" group by
Turkey and an offshoot of its outlawed Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK). Iraqi
Kurdish authorities said the young woman "had left the Women's Protection Units
(the YPG's female equivalent) and started a relationship with a PKK fighter
known as Toul Hadan, living in Bitlis," Turkey. "Both of them have decided to
leave the PKK," the interior ministry said in a statement. Dalia Mahmoud Muslim
traveled "clandestinely" to Turkey to hand herself over to Turkish authorities,
it said. On Sunday, her father, Mahmoud Muslim, said Iraqi Kurdish authorities
bore "responsibility for her kidnapping or for handing her over to Turkish
intelligence", adding that any comments attributed to her were "false" and
obtained "under pressure."Writing on Facebook, he said his daughter had traveled
to neighboring Iraq's Kurdish region six months ago for medical treatment and
had been preparing to return to Syria when she was "handed over to the Turkish
authorities."Saleh Muslim was himself briefly detained in Prague in 2018 and
Turkey demanded he be extradited, on the basis of a Turkish arrest warrant
issued two years earlier over an attack in Ankara that killed 29 people in
February 2016. He denied any link to the attack and was released. The Kurds
established a semi-autonomous administration -- viewed with hostility by Ankara
-- in the vast stretches of northeastern Syria that border Turkey during the
ongoing civil war. Iraqi Kurdish authorities, dominated by the Kurdistan
Democratic Party (KDP), see the PKK as rivals and been unable to uproot them
from their northern Iraqi bases. The PKK, which has waged a three-decade
insurgency against the Turkish state, has long used the rugged terrain of
northern Iraq as a rear base to attack Turkey, which in turn has set up military
positions inside Iraqi territory.
Top Democrats 'Gravely Concerned' over Foreign Interference
in U.S. Election
Agence France Presse/Naharnet/July 20/2020
Senior U.S. Democrats demanded an urgent intelligence briefing for lawmakers
from the FBI on Monday over what they said was a concerted foreign campaign to
spread disinformation to interfere in November's election.
"We are gravely concerned, in particular, that Congress appears to be the target
of a concerted foreign interference campaign, which seeks to launder and amplify
disinformation in order to influence congressional activity, public debate, and
the presidential election in November," said House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, the
Senate's senior Democrat Chuck Schumer and two others in a letter.
Israel Probes Palestinian Jerusalem Governor over
'Terrorism'
Agence France Presse/Naharnet/July 20/2020
Israel is investigating the Palestinian governor of Jerusalem over suspected
"terrorism", in the first such allegation against the often-arrested leader, his
lawyer said Monday. Adnan Ghaith has been arrested by Israeli security forces
more than 10 times over the past two years, but typically over the minor offense
of engaging in "illegal" political activities in the disputed city. He has
generally been released within a day or two. But Ghaith's lawyer Mohammed
Mahmoud told AFP that in addition to political offenses the governor was being
probed over "planning an act of terrorism," and not expected to be released
soon. Under Israeli law, a broad range of offenses fall under the terrorism
umbrella, and the probe does not necessarily mean Ghaith is suspected of
plotting an act of violence. It was the first time Ghaith was the subject of a
terrorism investigation and Israel's powerful domestic security agency, the Shin
Bet, was involved in the case, Mahmoud said. The Shin Bet did not immediately
respond to a query about the investigation. Police spokesman Micky Rosenfeld
told AFP that Ghaith had been arrested at his east Jerusalem home on Sunday.
"He is being questioned by security forces," Rosenfeld said. Israel occupied
east Jerusalem in the 1967 Six-Day War and later annexed it in a move never
recognized by the international community. It considers the entire city its
capital, while the Palestinians see the eastern sector as the capital of their
future state. Israel bans all Palestinian Authority activities in the city. As a
result, the PA has a minister for Jerusalem affairs and a Jerusalem governor
located in Al-Ram, just on the other side of an Israeli wall that separates the
city and the occupied West Bank. Ghaith has repeatedly been arrested for
allegedly carrying out PA activities in east Jerusalem, including for working to
ensure Palestinians in the city had access to essential services in the battle
against coronavirus.
Egypt Parliament Greenlights Possible Intervention in Libya
Agence France Presse/Naharnet/July 20/2020
Egypt's parliament on Monday greenlighted a possible deployment of troops
outside its borders, after President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi spoke of potential
military operations in neighboring Libya. The parliament unanimously approved
"the deployment of members of the Egyptian armed forces on combat missions
outside Egypt's borders to defend Egyptian national security ... against
criminal armed militias and foreign terrorist elements," it said in a statement.
Troubled Trump to Relaunch His Coronavirus Briefings
Agence France Presse/Naharnet/July 20/2020
U.S. President Donald Trump said Monday he will soon resume his televised
coronavirus briefings, signalling a bid to regain control of the message when
public dismay at his handling of the pandemic risks sinking his reelection bid.
A fierce surge of COVID-19 case in populous states like Florida and Texas is
straining Trump's sunny insistence that the virus will just "disappear" to its
breaking point. Polls show public trust in his management of the crisis
plummeting and predict a drubbing by Democratic challenger Joe Biden in the
election in just over 100 days.
Trump, a lifelong real estate salesman and more recently reality TV performer,
says the real problem is that Americans just aren't hearing the right news. So
probably from Tuesday, he will resume the regular evening televised briefings
from the White House that he did until late April -- often finding himself
accused of giving confusing or misleading information. "I think it's a great way
to get information out to the public," he told reporters. "We're doing very well
in so many different ways."Trump acknowledged a "big flare-up" of cases across
the south and west of the country but once again distanced himself from
responsibility for the problem, underlining that the disease is also ravaging
"Mexico, Brazil, many countries in Europe, all over, Russia.""When you watch the
news, the local news, and you see it, and it's, it's like all about the United
States. They never like to talk about what's going on in the world," he said.
Trump said the briefings would focus on good news regarding vaccine development
and therapeutics. "We think we're doing very well in that regard," he said. "I
think I'm going to be bringing in some of the great companies that are working
very successfully.""We're really coming up with some very good answers," he
said.
- PR fiasco -
Trump has great faith in his ability before the cameras. He has transformed the
image of the U.S. presidency during his first term with unprecedented streams of
press conferences, tweets and rallies. But his previous spell as the nation's
pandemic-spokesman in chief ended badly in late April. Trump often turned what
were billed as opportunities to provide the anxious public with information into
testy exchanges with reporters in the White House briefing room. He finally
ditched the events after a PR fiasco where he mused on air about the possibility
of injecting household disinfectant to combat COVID-19. He later said he had
been speaking "sarcastically," although there was no evidence of that at the
time.
- Polls slide -
The president has consistently sought to play down the severity of the health
crisis, hoping that voters will instead focus on what he touts as his good
management of the economy. In an interview with "Fox News Sunday," he once again
claimed that the virus, which has killed more than 140,000 Americans and caused
massive economic disruption, would somehow go away by itself. "I'll be right
eventually," he said. But with the virus on the rebound, he finds himself
accused of failing to lead. Biden has opened a double-digit lead in election
polls, and an ABC/ Washington Post poll released Friday showed nearly two-thirds
of Americans mistrust Trump on the coronavirus. Trump, nevertheless, appears to
be looking forward to his chance to get back to the briefing room podium. "We
had very successful briefings. I was doing them and we had a lot of people
watching, record numbers watching. In the history of cable television, there's
never been anything like it," he said.
The Latest LCCC English analysis &
editorials from miscellaneous sources published on July 20-21/2020
Remembering the AMIA Bombing: Why It Matters 26 Years Later
Toby Dershowitz/FDD/July 20/2020
Alberto Nisman, the tireless Argentine prosecutor who led the decade-long
investigation into the bombing of the 1994 AMIA Jewish community center in
downtown Buenos Aires, once told me that when Argentina’s president Nestor
Kirchner asked him to take on the case, he said to the president that he would
only do so under one condition. “What is that condition?” the president asked.
Nisman answered, “That I be allowed to take the investigation wherever the
evidence leads.”
In Argentina, such independence is far from a given. Prior to Nisman taking over
the case, Judge Juan Jose Galeano was removed from office and impeached for
mishandling the investigation into the bombing.
Nisman’s investigation had found that Iranian officials at the highest levels of
government had planned and directed the bombing, whose youngest victim,
Sebastian Barreiro, was only five years old. He died holding his mother’s hand
as they walked in front of the building. The oldest victim, Faiwel Pablo
Dyjament, was a 73-year-old tailor. Eighty-three others were killed in the
attack on the community center.
Based on Nisman’s granular investigation, in 2007, INTERPOL issued red notices,
akin to wanted-persons notices, requesting law enforcement worldwide to locate
and provisionally arrest perpetrators of the bombing when they travel
internationally. Five red notices against Iranian officials and one against a
Lebanese Hezbollah official remain in force today.
Iran and Lebanon have never turned over the accused to stand trial. Argentina
does not allow trials in absentia. Justice has not been served.
Nisman had come to suspect something was amiss. In 2015, he exposed a cover-up
involving then-President Cristina Fernandez de Kirchner. For this, Nisman
ultimately paid with his life. He was found murdered the day before he was to
present evidence to the Argentine Congress contending that Cristina Kirchner
sought to whitewash Iran’s role in the deadliest terrorist attack in the
country’s history.
In 2017, federal judge Claudio Bonadio found—based on the case Nisman had
built—that there was preliminary evidence that Kirchner, as president, and 11
others, sought to erase Iran’s role in the bombing in exchange for expanded
trade and perhaps other benefits. His finding came after she left the
presidential palace and became a senator, where she received partial immunity
and avoided incarceration. The trial is still pending and there is doubt as to
whether it will ever take place.
Remembering the AMIA bombing still matters 26 years later because Argentina has
not entirely come to terms with holding accountable those responsible for the
attack. Although last year Argentina finally designated Hezbollah as a terrorist
organization and froze assets of Hezbollah financiers—an important step—the
terror group continues to operate in northern Argentina and in the porous
Tri-Border Area with Paraguay and Brazil, where the AMIA bombers reportedly
entered the country prior to the attack. Argentina needs to step up and actively
thwart Hezbollah’s malign activities.
It matters because, notwithstanding the evidence of Iran’s role in masterminding
the attack, then-President Kirchner’s government signed in 2013 a Memorandum of
Understanding (MOU) with Tehran that would have created the appearance of
jointly investigating the bombing—akin to an arsonist “investigating” the fire
he had himself set. If implemented, the MOU might have caused the red notices to
be lifted. INTERPOL should not lift the red notices until the accused stand
trial. And an Argentine court found the MOU itself to be unconstitutional.
It matters because in 2013, INTERPOL suspiciously placed “caveats” or “waivers”
on the red notices, such that they acted more like flashing yellow lights than
true red lights. When the accused travel, their notices could be overlooked.
Indeed, since 2007, red notice holders and those with Argentine arrest warrants
implicated in the planning and directing of the AMIA attack have traveled with
impunity to more than 20 countries. Law enforcement should ensure the red
notices are enforced.
It matters because as vice president, a position she now holds, Mrs. Kirchner
has sought to unwind the legal case against herself and others implicated in the
cover-up by placing close associates in positions of power to achieve precisely
that.
It matters because while Alberto Fernandez in 2015 dismissed portrayals of
Nisman’s murder as a suicide—he said, “no one in Argentina thinks it was
suicide, absolutely no one, least of all Cristina Fernández de Kirchner”—he has,
since his election to the presidency in 2019, done a 180. Fernandez is heard on
Netflix in early 2020 saying, “until now no serious evidence has appeared saying
Nisman was killed.” Moreover, in recent months, new Fernandez appointees have
reportedly interfered with the ongoing investigation. The president is mindful
that it was Mrs. Kirchner who originally planted the discredited theory that
Nisman committed suicide, hours after the prosecutor was found dead.
If Nisman committed suicide, there would be no need to hold anyone accountable.
If he had been murdered, questions about who ordered the murder and who carried
it out would need to be answered; culprits would have to be held accountable.
Argentine officials have sought to sew confusion about the murder, but these
questions must be answered in a transparent process.
It matters because Argentina’s current minister of security, Sabina Frederic,
said that the prior administration’s designation of Hezbollah as a terrorist
organization amounts to “buying a problem we don’t have.” Fortunately, federal
judge Miguel Angel Guerrero of Misiones, who has jurisdiction over this,
extended the designation for one more year, freezing financial assets belonging
to Hezbollah, the Barakat clan and other Hezbollah operatives. He and President
Fernandez deserve recognition for this. However, given the all-too-frequent
threats made to judges, prosecutors and witnesses, the Argentine government must
now ensure the safety of the judge who made that determination and ensure it is
robustly enforced.
It matters because Nisman’s investigation into the AMIA bombing provides a
roadmap for law enforcement to understand Iranian penetration of Latin
America—and, indeed, the entire Western Hemisphere.
And it matters because the 85 victims of the AMIA bombing, along with all of
Argentina, deserve to have those who planned and executed the bombing—and those
who sought to cover up Iran’s role—held accountable.
There are signs that President Fernandez is seeking to make amends by reaching
out to Jewish communities both domestically and abroad. His outreach is hopeful.
But on this 26th anniversary of the worst terrorist attack in the country’s
history and with the backdrop of so many cover-ups in the past, we owe it to the
AMIA victims to ensure his outstretched arm produces real justice, not just one
more cover-up.
*Toby Dershowitz is senior vice president at the Foundation for Defense of
Democracies, a nonpartisan think tank focusing on national security issues.
Follow her on Twitter @tobydersh.
Tehran Consolidates Hardline Gains At Home While COVID-19
Spreads
Behnam Ben Taleblu and Saeed Ghasseminejad/Radio Farda/July 20/2020
Iran experienced its highest-ever record of coronavirus-related deaths in just
one day earlier this month, bringing the official number of reported deaths
since late February to more than 13,000. These deaths follow a widely reported
second peak of confirmed coronavirus infections from early June. Despite this
trend, as well as Iran’s status as a regional hub for the virus, the Islamic
Republic has not used the pandemic as an opportunity to moderate its behavior or
improve the function of government at home.
It’s tempting to see the Islamic Republic’s response to COVID-19 as mere
incompetence, perhaps best exemplified through various city-wide lockdowns that
were short-lived. But this ignores the strongly opportunistic and ideological
streak in many Iranian officials who are pressing ahead with their longstanding
revolutionary, Islamist, and authoritarian agendas, all of which puts the
regime’s interest ahead of the national interest.
Nowhere is this clearer than the Islamic Republic’s treatment of its own
citizens. As reported in June, Iranian police have been increasing their
crackdown on citizens posting pictures on social media in violation of Islamic
social mores and the country’s mandatory hijab, or headscarf, policy. Later that
month, hardliner lawmakers in parliament entertained the idea of enacting a
nationwide ban on Instagram. Between a quarter to over one-half of the
population uses Instagram, which is not blocked like Facebook, Twitter, or
Telegram. With Iranians spending longer hours at home (and assumedly more time
online) due to the pandemic, their limited privacy and freedom is again coming
under attack.
Spurning U.S. offers of humanitarian assistance, earlier this year Iran’s
supreme leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei insinuated that Washington was behind the
virus
The extent of the crackdown, however, far surpasses aggressively policing social
media and making arrests. The employment of lethal force to settle political
scores is also occurring. Just days ago, Human Rights Watch reported that
Iranian courts upheld a death penalty order for three protestors who partook in
demonstrations in 2019. The case has prompted massive social recoil online, but
the Iranian judiciary has not formally repealed the sentence to date. To make
matters worse, all three men were reportedly tortured while in custody. And in
April, lethal force was used against protestors in prison who were rioting
against the potential spread of Coronavirus in jails. According to Amnesty
International, 35 prisoners were killed. Media outlets like Radio Farda have
documented the concerns of Iranian prisoners who fear they and their cellmates
have been exposed to the virus. Tehran has largely ignored their fears.
Instead, the Islamic Republic has opted to use this time to promote a dangerous
troika of conspiracy theories, disinformation, and pseudoscience. Spurning U.S.
offers of humanitarian assistance, earlier this year Iran’s supreme leader
Ayatollah Ali Khamenei insinuated that Washington was behind the virus and that
the U.S. is led by “charlatans and liars.” Other Iranian officials have said
their country is ready and willing to offer Americans its own assistance.
Khamenei’s explanation for the growth of the virus in the West? A “failure of
the western social philosophy,” one of his favorite talking points. Such
thinking helps to explain the rejection of help from the internationally
renowned Doctors Without Borders, as well as the decision to tout potential
Russo-Iranian cooperation against the coronavirus.
Other predictable talking points from the Iranian elite include the allegation
that the virus may have been an American biological weapon, a point made by
Hossein Salami, the commander of Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC).
One casualty of such thinking is that pseudoscience is set to be
institutionalized in higher education in Iran. The regime is mandating that
university-level medical students take classes in what Tehran calls “Islamic
medicine” or “traditional medicine.” Earlier this year, proponents of such
medicine endorsed grossly unscientific remedies to deal with the coronavirus.
These reportedly ranged from drinking camel urine to even placing a violet
oil-soaked cotton-ball into the anus at night.
Iran has been hesitant to go into a full nationwide lockdown, hoping to continue
its strategy of promoting regional and non-oil trade to outlast the Trump
administration’s maximum pressure policy
Similarly, Iran’s Basij paramilitary, an arm of the IRGC, has developed a
so-called coronavirus scanner. According to reports, the machine could allegedly
detect the virus within 100 meters during a five-second scan. The claim, as well
as the haphazard machine itself, faced significant pushback from within the
scientific community in Iran.
In this context Iranian authorities have focused on the coronavirus almost
exclusively through the lens of regime security. As first noted by scholars of
Iranian security policy, several months ago, Tehran created a new base dubbed
the Imam Hassan Headquarters to oversee and coordinate state responses to those
afflicted by COVID-19. By placing the IRGC – which is well versed in domestic
suppression – at the commanding heights of Iran’s COVID-19 management, Tehran is
signaling that it is prepared to use these forces to crush any potential
protests related to the regime’s handling of the coronavirus that aren’t
bought-off through the headquarters’ various charitable activities. It is also
seeking to promote sympathy and support for the IRGC inside Iran, calling those
IRGC members who have died from the virus “martyrs.”
Still, some protests have continued, albeit in more localized pockets and on a
smaller scale. The lingering grievances, coupled with the regime’s botched
response to the disease, are causing some politicians to raise the specter of
wider protests in the near future. Iranian President Hassan Rouhani claimed in
April that a full lockdown would hurt the economy and bring the “hungry” into
the streets.
Thus, Iran has been hesitant to go into a full nationwide lockdown, hoping to
continue its strategy of promoting regional and non-oil trade to outlast the
Trump administration’s maximum pressure policy. Even prior to the onset of
COVID-19, Iran’s economy was already reeling. The pandemic thus served as an
accelerant to both foreign and domestic sources of pressure on the country’s
economy. That is why Rouhani, when facing new data in July, again linked the
policy option of a lock-down to producing more protests. Even members of
Rouhani’s own government, such as the minister of health, are warning about an
economically driven revolt led by lower-income Iranians.
This reality offers the Trump administration an opportunity to press its message
about the incongruence between the actions of the Iranian government and the
demands and needs of the Iranian people. In its messaging toward the Iranian
people, Washington should highlight more than just Iran’s botched response to
the coronavirus. By underscoring Iran’s conspiracy theories, pseudoscience, and
domestic repression, it should show how even during a pandemic, the Islamic
Republic has failed to put, for lack of a better phrase, “Iran first.”
*Behnam Ben Taleblu is a senior fellow at the Foundation for Defense of
Democracies (FDD) in Washington D.C., where he covers Iranian political and
security issues. *Saeed Ghasseminejad is a senior Iran and financial economics
advisor at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies (FDD), where he also
contributes to FDD’s Center on Economic and Financial Power (CEFP). Follow Saeed
on Twitter @SGhasseminejad.
Turkey’s Bar Associations Become the Latest Target of Erdogan’s Iran-Inspired
“Reform”
Aykan Erdemir and Philip Kowalski/Policy Brief/July 20/2020
The Turkish parliament passed a controversial law on July 11 to allow the
creation of multiple bar associations in each of Turkey’s 81 provinces, amending
the existing system that stipulates only one association per province. This move
by Turkey’s ruling Islamist-ultranationalist coalition is its latest attempt to
bring bar associations and their national umbrella organization under greater
government control by institutionalizing an Iran-inspired system that will favor
pro-regime lawyers.
A lawmaker from Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s Justice and Development
Party (AKP) claimed in June that the new law is necessary because “bar
associations were no longer able to function properly following a 13-fold
increase in the number of lawyers in Turkey.” The AKP purports the reforms will
lead to a more democratic and pluralistic system while addressing the
dysfunctional aspects of the current system. Unimpressed by such promises, 78
out of 80 bar associations signed a statement opposing the reforms and organized
protests ahead of the vote in parliament.
In reality, the reforms are aimed at reducing the power of Turkey’s staunchly
pro-secular bar associations and increasing the relative weight of associations
in smaller provinces, where Erdogan has greater sway. Under the existing system,
Turkey’s three biggest bar associations, located in the country’s most populous
cities – Istanbul, Ankara, and Izmir – elect 221 of the 477 delegates to the
national umbrella association. The new law will bring the total number of
delegates down to 26. This move to disempower the largest associations is
retaliation for their vocal criticism of the government’s breaches of human
rights and the rule of law.
During deliberation of the bill in parliament, an opposition lawmaker accused
the new law of creating “parallel bar associations.” By allowing multiple bar
associations in provinces with over 5,000 registered lawyers, the new law will
split them along political lines. That, in turn, will allow prosecutors and
judges to favor defense teams comprising members of pro-government bar
associations, punishing lawyers who belong to independent bar associations.
The Turkish government’s move appears to have been modeled after the Islamic
Republic’s machinations to strengthen its hold over the Iranian judicial system.
Prior to the Islamic Revolution in 1979, the Iranian bar association was highly
regarded both at home and abroad, in a manner comparable to its associates in
countries such as France and the United Kingdom. The revolution led to growing
pressure on independent lawyers, whom the theocratic government suspected of
being secular and pro-Western. Since then, the Islamic Republic has had a
history of appointing pro-government clerics to top judicial positions, none of
whom had any formal legal training or academic background in law. In 2001, the
Iranian regime created a parallel body of lawyers called the Legal Advisors of
the Judiciary, which works directly under the supervision of the judiciary. In
May, the Islamic Republic prepared a draft bill aiming to further undermine the
country’s independent bar association by creating yet another parallel
institution, namely, “the Supreme Council for the Coordination of Lawyers’
Affairs.”
Given the disastrous state of Iran’s justice system, critics are right to fear
where Erdogan’s judicial reforms will lead. The creation of multiple bar
associations will further erode the rule of law and due process in Turkey and
significantly weaken Turkish dissidents’ ability to defend themselves against
the government-controlled judiciary’s politically motivated charges. The growing
convergence between Erdogan’s Turkey and Iran should be a wake-up call to
Western policy makers and analysts who expect Ankara to provide a counterweight
to the Islamic Republic’s malign influence in the Middle East and beyond.
*Aykan Erdemir is a former member of the Turkish parliament and senior director
of the Turkey Program at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies (FDD), where
*Philip Kowalski is a research associate. For more analysis from Aykan, Philip,
and FDD, please subscribe HERE. Follow Aykan and Philip on Twitter @aykan_erdemir
and @philip_kowalski. Follow FDD on Twitter @FDD. FDD is a Washington, DC-based,
nonpartisan research institute focusing on national security and foreign policy.
Why last weekend’s G20 meeting of finance ministers and
central bank governors mattered
Cornelia Meyer/Arab News/July 21, 2020
Amid the EU summit in Brussels and controversy about Huawei’s involvement in the
rollout of the 5G infrastructure in the UK and elsewhere, last weekend’s meeting
of the G20’s finance ministers and central bank governors was largely overlooked
by the international media — especially as it came on the heels of the big banks
in the US reporting their Q2 earnings. It was an important meeting nonetheless:
While the tone of the finance ministers and central bank governors may not grab
headlines, what they discussed was vital to the global economy, especially when
faced with the economic fallout of the coronavirus disease (COVID-19). The
ministers and central bank governors said that though the outlook was still
depressed due to the pandemic, they expected economic activity to pick up. They
reiterated their commitment to support emerging, developing and low-income
economies.
In line with the focus of Saudi Arabia’s presidency of this year’s G20, the
ministers reiterated that inclusive and sustainable growth stood front and
center of their agendas. They also stressed that monetary and fiscal policies
would be deployed for as long as they were needed to deal with the economic
fallout of the pandemic.
The meeting also endorsed policies decided during their April 15 gathering,
where they focused on the actions taken by multilateral development institutions
like the International Monetary Fund (IMF), the World Bank Group and regional
development banks. They stated they endeavored to “address the vulnerabilities
in low income countries due to the pandemic,” and enhance “coordination among
international organizations to maximize their impact and optimize the use of
resources.”
This may sound like lip service, but these multilateral organizations will
provide $200 billion to cash-strapped developing countries. Ayman Sejiny, CEO of
the Islamic Corporation for the Development of the Private Sector, one of three
private sector entities of the Islamic Development Bank, based in Jeddah,
observed: “The G20 were vital in ensuring the seamless cooperation of
multilateral and bilateral lending communities to support developing countries
throught the COVID-19 induced economic turmoil.”
What is particularly important here is the debt service moratorium for the
poorest countries and the fact that the G20 secured the concurrence of the Paris
Club, where officials from debtor nations try to find coordinated and
sustainable solutions to the payment difficulties experienced by debtor nations.
So far, 42 have applied to benefit from the Debt Service Suspension Initiative (DSSI),
and the total sum involved equates to $5.2 billion. The G20’s clout with major
commercial financial institutions also means that there is pressure on them to
find accommodations with debtor nations, be it in the framework of the London
Club or elsewhere. The foundations for the above were laid in April. However,
one cannot overemphasize how important the G20 and also the B20 are in this
context. It is becoming increasingly difficult to get the international
community to speak with one voice, as the US and China go toe to toe on many
geopolitical and economic issues. (The latest wrangling over the participation
of Chinese telecoms giant Huawei in the buildout of the 5G infrastructure, is a
case in point, as is the US withdrawal from the WHO or the UN’s Paris Agreement
on climate change.)
The pandemic is a global problem necessitating global solutions. IMF Managing
Director Kristalina Georgieva had warned that the poorest countries might be
among the worst affected by its economic fallout, which makes it all the more
important that the world stands together when it comes to COVID-19 response
packages.
There may be disagreement on reallocating special drawing rights in the IMF, how
long the debt moratorium should last in for, or whether it should be extended to
more countries (The World Bank would like to see the DSSI extended through 2021
and the scope of the deal broadened).
Wherever you have many participants in a discussion, you will always have many
competing voices. The fact these issues are being discussed means there is
global concern, which is positive.
It is lucky that Saudi Arabia holds the G20 presidency for 2020, because the
Kingdom has influence and can bridge the gap between great powers when they do
not see eye to eye. The weakest of the weak are in desperate need for the world
to come together in their support, which is what seems to be happening.
• Cornelia Meyer is a business consultant, macro-economist and energy expert.
Twitter: @MeyerResources
Egypt’s strong military message to Turkey, Tunisia
Dr. Abdellatif El-Menawy/Arab News/July 21, 2020
The drums of war on the Libyan-Egyptian border are not beating in the way we are
familiar with. Their echo is resonating everywhere in the world. Although not
conventional, these drums of war are growing louder and louder.
Last month, Egyptian President Abdel Fattah El-Sisi warned of the readiness of
his country’s army to intervene both within and outside its borders, in a clear
reference to the conflict in neighboring Libya. By saber-rattling on Egypt’s
western border with Libya, El-Sisi wanted to send clear and strong messages to
all: The Egyptian forces are ready to enter any confrontation, and with any
party, in order to protect Egypt’s national security.
“Any direct intervention in Libya will be aimed at securing the border,” the
president said, adding that “any direct intervention by Egypt now has
international legitimacy,” and that “some think they can trespass on the Sirte
or Al-Jufra front lines. This, for us, is a red line. As long as the neighboring
countries are stable, Egypt is stable. This is what the distant and near history
has taught us, and so did the Egyptian military doctrine, which only intervenes
if asked. This happened in the 1948 war in Palestine against Zionist gangs and
in the 1991 war for the liberation of Kuwait.”
Egypt has always prioritized Egyptian security first and then Arab security in
shouldering its responsibilities and playing its national role, not caring about
losses and profits, in support of its well-established values, principles and
doctrine.
History is now repeating itself, with Turkey’s flagrant threat to Egypt’s red
lines, both in Libya and in the Mediterranean.
El-Sisi’s saber-rattling on Libya, urging his military to be ready to carry out
any mission outside the country and beating of the drums of “war preparedness,”
is well grounded. As per the Egyptian military doctrine, Egypt will never be the
initiator or the aggressor. We are not lost on the high price we paid for our
commitment to this doctrine during the Six-Day War in 1967. Egypt then adhered
to the calls and demands of the Arab leaders not to be the initiator of war, so
Israel surprised us with its strikes. Egypt, by now asserting its readiness and
preparedness for war, is not saying that war is coming. However, it is trying to
send various signals on a large number of fronts. The first signal is purely
political, as Egypt seeks during this period to restore its great and positive
role in the Arab and African regions. The participation of the Egyptian
president and state officials in more than one political meeting in this context
confirms this point.It goes without saying that political and diplomatic
meetings need strong support. The Egyptian military’s strength — it is ranked
ninth in the world according to the Global Firepower Index — comes in support of
the political stature that Egypt is now building.
“Oh Egypt, your golden sun has returned,” is not just a song title by the iconic
Lebanese singer Fairuz, but is also a reality imposed by the events since 2014,
with an important and vital presence established at all levels. A large number
of the countries of the world now support what the Egyptian state is instilling
in Libya through its continuous calls for peace and legitimacy there. Another
reality that solidifies and emphasizes the prominent role that Egypt plays in
our time is its just position on the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (GERD).
The second signal is internal, addressed to the Egyptian people. The strength of
the Egyptian military has become clear to the Egyptians after criticism of the
government’s spending priorities. A large group of Egyptians were criticizing
the issue of the country spending so much money on weapons they described as
unused, referring in this context to the purchases of French Rafale aircraft,
Mistral-class German ships and others. They advised the Egyptian state to
instead direct this spending to some dying sectors, such as health and
education.
These critics lack a clear vision, as they have been unable to see what the
Egyptian leadership is trying to prove by balancing spending on important and
vital services with spending on armaments, which has become a necessity in this
volatile region.
President El-Sisi’s parading before the armed forces undoubtedly sent a message
of reassurance to the Egyptian people, who are now well aware of the strength of
their army and its ability to tackle the many dangers it faces during this
period.
Following the Jan. 25, 2011, revolution, Egyptians were left with doubts about
the strength of their army and its ability to face threats to national security.
The Muslim Brotherhood, which ruled Egypt between 2012 and 2013, is to be blamed
for kindling these doubts, which the new government, El-Sisi and the military
leaders have tirelessly tried to suppress. The Egyptian people regained
confidence in their army after seeing it on many occasions, on televisions and
in newspapers, parading with their new equipment and weapons. The most recent
exhibition was when El-Sisi visited the military detachment in Egypt’s western
region near the border with Libya.
The readiness to fight at any time or place and under any circumstances is a
well-established doctrine of the Egyptian army. The image of the Egyptian
government, people and army standing united sends a very important message of
deterrence to anyone who believes that confrontation with Egypt is easy or who
wants to exploit a fictitious division of opinions on the nature of the tasks
and priorities of the Egyptian state. All Egyptians stand united, in heart and
soul, when it comes to their security. The message of deterrence is very
important as Egypt already has a shield to protect it and a sword on the necks
of those who are thinking of attacking it by land or sea. Egypt also has a
strong diplomacy that is globally effective, can clarify the Egyptian right
before all forums, and ensure international legitimacy for all its actions.
As per the Egyptian military doctrine, Egypt will never be the initiator or the
aggressor.
Finally, by showcasing its readiness to fight anywhere, at any time, Egypt is
sending a signal to foreign countries and to the Turkish and Ethiopian
leaderships in particular. Egypt and its military will never be silent about
threats to its national security, whether at the territorial level in Libya or
at the level of water rights amid the continuing Ethiopian procrastination and
prevarication during the GERD negotiations.
The signals are not only military, but also political, which is characteristic
of the Egyptian administration today, as it can operate on many fronts with the
same efficiency and adeptness.
*Dr. Abdellatif El-Menawy is a critically acclaimed multimedia journalist,
writer and columnist who has covered war zones and conflicts worldwide. Twitter:
@ALMenawy
Disclaimer: Views expressed by writers in this section are their own and do not
necessarily reflect Arab News' point-of-view
UN reform essential but unlikely to happen
Chris Doyle/Arab News/July 21, 2020
The Second World War was not even over when the UN Charter was written. The
conference that opened in San Francisco in April 1945 was where the Charter was
created and formally signed by the 50 participating nations. Now, three-quarters
of a century later, the UN is a body of 193 members. Its founding aim was to
“save succeeding generations from the scourge of war” — a mighty ambition,
coming after two global conflicts had destroyed generations across the planet.
How has this body fared? Has it achieved the lofty aims of its progenitors, or
even got close? Was this too naive an ambition?
It is easy to carp and pass judgment. Countless conflicts have ensued, with
terrible consequences, some within just a few years of that San Francisco
gathering, like the Korean War. Yet, for all the tensions and rivalries, not
least during the Cold War era, a third world war has yet to erupt. And those few
occasions that did take us to the brink — such as the Cuban Missile Crisis —
were largely a result of accident and miscalculation, rather than any serious
desire for world domination.
The UN should take credit for its role in evading a third world war thus far.
Back at the height of the Cold War, the Security Council was frequently the
forum where fevered tensions were calmed. The US and Soviet Union could deploy
the veto to cancel each other out diplomatically, but also use it for
face-saving purposes.
This hardly gets pulses racing in the peace-making fraternity, but it should not
be downplayed. It must not be forgotten and cast aside as one rips apart the
organization’s inglorious failings. One must also be candid about expectations
of keeping peace across the world when so many conflict fault lines, historical
grievances and ancient antipathies prevail.
The other cautionary point is that any such body is only ever as effective as
its members allow it to be. Rifts and division paralyze the UN, as we witness
today over Syria and Libya. The vetoes of the permanent five members of the
Security Council can be viewed as a necessary evil to keep the UN from breaking
up. These nations have protected their separate interests but also their allies
from censure or action. All too frequently, critics claim that the UN failed
over, say, Palestine or Iraq, when really it is individual states to blame.
The credit column must also include the phenomenal aid, relief and development
efforts. Many UN agencies operate in the harshest of circumstances, saving the
lives of millions. Is it always sound value for money? No, frequently not, but
agencies such as UNICEF, the UN Development Program, and the UN High
Commissioner for Refugees are irreplaceable in delivering aid at scale. Often
they succeed despite the UN’s bureaucracy and the bickering and interference of
its members.
Not all UN agencies have hit the heights. The UN Human Rights Council is not fit
for purpose. Member states are hardly going to be impartial judges and juries on
their own behavior. Accountability in international relations remains weak to
nonexistent, with the International Criminal Court (ICC) chastised for having
only indicted African figures in its short history. Many will wait to see if the
ICC dares to probe Israelis for war crimes.
Palestine has to rank as one of the UN’s greatest failures. The UN General
Assembly (UNGA) gave birth to the state of Israel with the 1947 UNGA 181, the
partition resolution. More than seven decades later, the UN has yet to welcome
the state of Palestine as a full member. The US, in particular, has, since 1967,
gone to extraordinary lengths to shield Israel from legitimate charges of war
crimes. But have the other nations done enough to counter this?
Other notable failures include Rwanda and Darfur. Many are rightly still haunted
by the failure of the UN and other parties to do anything to prevent these
genocides. They are a stain on the UN’s record that cannot be wiped away.
The UN has suffered its fair share of humiliations, but perhaps none worse than
during the wars that saw the breakup of the former Yugoslavia. In 1995, Bosnian
Serbs held 400 UN observers hostage and used them as human shields. Even though
Srebrenica was declared a UN safe zone, 7,000 men and boys were massacred in
just a few days under the noses of UN peacemakers.
One would like to think that this anniversary will spark a serious effort to
renew and reform this great body. It will not happen. Past efforts have withered
away. The permanent members are not going to give up their veto or risk diluting
this golden power by offering it out to too many other states. Increasingly, the
UN risks becoming an irrelevance as rival actors ignore international law and
diplomacy in their nakedly raw quest for supremacy. Can the UN also handle the
mega-threats of our age? Transnational terrorism and organized crime have proved
too much. One can only hope that the UN can bring nations together to address
climate change, but who would bet on it?
One would like to think that this anniversary will spark a serious effort to
renew and reform this great body.
The UN also needs to address perhaps its greatest failing. The UN Charter itself
memorably starts with, “We the peoples of the United Nations…” This remains a
manifest falsehood. The peoples of the UN do not have a say. This is a body of
states, whose leaders take the decisions. It serves their interests, not the
people's and, in particular, those of the major powers. It is not remotely
democratic, neither are many of its members.
Herein lies the challenge. How, over the next quarter of a century, can the
behemoth of the UN metamorphose into a body relevant to the challenges of the
times and in touch with the peoples of each continent? Many might ask whether it
can adapt at all. But, if it wants to survive, it surely has to.
*Chris Doyle is director of the London-based Council for Arab-British
Understanding. Twitter: @Doylech